MAC - Chill Collection Discussion

Winthrop44

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chrystia
Based on what I've been playing around with at the counter, I don't feel like this is a great collection. Most of the eyeshadows can be duped as can the lip shades.

I will be curious to see how everyone likes the penultimate liner. I know our trainer was very excited about it and many of my co workers are. Personally I thought it looked too much like a marker on the skin. I will continue to spread my love of fluidline instead.


Is there a dupe in the perm line for Wintersky?
 

blindpassion

Well-known member
I got to swatch the penultimate liner at the my counter the other day.

I am definitely buying it. It can apply a tiny line or a thick one, its fabulous. I am so excited about it!
 

MAC_Whore

Well-known member
Chill is available online now. The promo image isn't up, but you can find the products by category, ie shadows, lipglass, etc.

Get spending.
winks.gif
 

NewlyMACd

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by nursee81
Is when is the release date for free standing stores?

Quote:
Originally Posted by blindpassion
December 26th ^

Ok well see now that makes sense. Mines is a freestanding store
 

genica

Well-known member
YAY! I just bought

Vellum e/s
Wintersky e/s
Artic Grey e/s
Icescape l/g
Frozen Dream l/g
Naked Frost l/g

I may be tempted to buy mont black, apres ski, or snowscene once I see them in person. But for now I just wanted my must-haves.
 

AdlersMommy22

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by damsel
^^^ ummm, they up the release date.


shows how much Ive been paying attention to this thread, considering i only want the liner. LOL!
 

sinergy

Well-known member
I cant decide if I need Mont Black! I havent seen enough swatches I guess
lol.gif
it looks pretty but maybe i have enough sparkly blacks to dupe it with??? but my for sure list is

Wintersky
Vellum
Snowscene

my maybe list
Icescape
Arctic Grey
Mont Black
 

Sanayhs

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by sinergy
I cant decide if I need Mont Black! I havent seen enough swatches I guess
lol.gif
it looks pretty but maybe i have enough sparkly blacks to dupe it with??? but my for sure list is

Wintersky
Vellum
Snowscene

my maybe list
Icescape
Arctic Grey
Mont Black


Quote:
Originally Posted by elegant-one
^^^I'm trying to decide if I want Mont Black also
th_dunno.gif


If you already have a sparkly black velvet eyeshadow from MAC (or something like the black diamond shadow from MUFE, you get the idea), I'd say don't bother. Honestly, though, how many sparkly blacks do you need?
 

Krasevayadancer

Well-known member
Ok ladies, I got to swatch and play yesterday. Sorry it took me so long to review, I am too freaking busy sometimes!

Here are my thoughts, no pics because my cam is brizoke and I don't get my new one till Chanukah. That also means no fotds for the next week!
ssad.gif


Generally, this collection was okay for me. Its small, and not relatively exciting. I must say I was unhappy with macs choices of eyeshadow formulas. Lustres and mattes suck! Frosts and velvets don't make me happy either. The lipglasses are very frosty, but the colors aren't overly unique at all. Boo to that. The liner, that is love. The end

I didn't swatch the lipglasses because they didn't excite me in the tube. Lots of frostiness, a bit of pearl, but not unique colors.

Eyeshadows:
Apres Ski- This one is a matte which inherently means its going to be hard to blend. When I swiped a finger across it felt like my beloved matte^2, but it swatched hardly at all. The color is a dark taupey grey. Wintersky- This one was my fav of the bunch. In the pot it looked a bit like expensive pink, but on my hand it was a gorgeous frosty light pink. It had a bit of a duochrome to it, but I can't recall the other color.
Mont Blanc- This is just like black tied only with gold flecks that dissapear when you swatch it. On the hand it looks just like black tied did. Did I mention I am not a fan of black tied and velvets in general?
Arctic Grey- I felt like this one had the potential to be an awesome shade of silver, which it is. The texture however gets me, as it is a satin. I do not like satins, and I didn't like how this one didn't apply with a great deal of pigmentation. Is it me or was arctic grey a lustre? I must be going nuts cause I remember it being a lustre, buts its labeled on here as a satin? :scratches head:
Vellum: Love the duochrome and the color, but I hate the finish and pigmentation on this one sadly
The glitters are both reflects- Transparent Teal and Antique Gold which are always fun but are also pro perm
smiles.gif


Penultimate Liner- Come to Mama! Haha. This one looked just like my beloved Chanel Pen. It is basically a clicky felt tip pen and I think it is awesome. I am very excited to have a cheaper option than Chanel in a liner that I love!
 

Sanayhs

Well-known member
I like satins. I rarely like lustres. If Arctic Grey makes you think lustre, that pretty much seals the deal that I don't need it. Did it remind you of any other silvers, by the way?
 

jdechant

Well-known member
Hmm....well I was thinking about getting this whole collection..but I may have to rethink that now! I'm also definitely getting the eyeliner pen... I <3 Chunky black liner and am always too afraid to try to achieve that with my fluidline..lol...The lashes look HAWT...and I don't mind Wintersky (would like to see swatches first though) I may also get a grey...I just don't know which one????? Ugghh..I was hoping this collection would be sooo much more!!
 
Chill is now released - Anyone getting this?

Hey, I just noticed that Chill has been released online. I thought it wasn't coming out until the 18th? oops today is the 16th so it's close enough. Would love to hear if anyone is going to get anything of this release or are you waiting for Dame Edna??
 

capmorlovesmac

Well-known member
Hmm.. I rethink my list now too. I think I will skip the l/g on my list and just get Wintersky e/s and
Reflects Transparent Teal. I am looking for a great grey e/s. Is there one in the perm line that you guys can recommend?
th_dunno.gif
 
Top