Between the holiday collection and this one you will haul quite a bit then I bet, I know you love mineralize products too. I actually preferred Naturally over Aprec Chic (less shimmery), so I'm hoping Divine Night will have great products like those. MES like Cloudy Afternoon, or Golden Gaze in fact, that don't have those added glittter particles like recent MES had would be just awesome.
I only have Superb and I'm not a fan. I guess it's just that I'm into more subtle and natural looks these days. I do love me some MSFs, but Superb is too shimmery for me, and admittedly I probably didn't get the hang of it yet how to apply it the right way. I also returned the ED blushes I got, and the e/s already look too shimmery in swatches, I'm more into matte and satin finishes lately. All in all, ED is just not tempting me because I feel like there are so many better options out there for me personally, like I'm really into Shiseido right now. The blushes (plus their white one as a highlighter) and the e/s are so fine and smooth and easy to handle.
Naturally had some nice MES, but those Naturally MBs, like Fresh Honey and Early Morning were just stupendous!!! None of the lipsticks in that collection worked at all for me, though. All were really off for my skin tone and I didn't get any of them. Apres Chic I felt was more balanced, with great colors in the lip products that picked up on all the future trends, while all still staying soft and gentle enough for every day wear and better designed for a range of different skin tones. The shadows weren't crazy glittery for me for some reason - maybe it was just the veining I picked or maybe it was the fact I preferred to wear that batch applied dry and buffed in a bit. And THOSE MBs were somewhat sparkly if you didn't buff them in and not a good choice to wear over foundation, but applied on their own over bare skin, they did absolute miracles for my dry older skin with zero effort. I totally adore them. I'd say it's the best MAC collection I've bought from where I could get the perfect no-makeup makeup look: Amber Glow on the cheeks, Rosy Romance on the lips or maybe Cozy Up and a little Fireside or Winter Pursuit on the eyes with some Night Trail liner. LOVE.
Didn't get any MSFs from either Naturally or Apres Chic - I honestly am not crazy about the older MSFs, at least compared to the newest ones from the past 2 years or so - those are the best. I'm still crazy about Semi Precious Goldstone, Pearl and Crystal Pink, Star Wonder and Light Year and of course, the gorgeoussssss Adored and Rio!!! I don't even touch any of my older MSFs - all of these are so much better!
As for the EDSFs, the newer ones are a little more subtle, but yeah, it's no joke about the ultra wet look they give, especially if applied with Fix+. They're another product I don't really like over foundation much, although strangely, the ED blushes were much more pigmented when worn over some base and honestly looked best that way, I thought.
This is one of the nice things about MAC. I appreciate that there are different products for different skin needs. I can't always wear the beauty powders - some of those just are the wrong texture for my skin, but then there are things like the EDSFs which are great for older skin and the MSFs that can work for many different skin types and requirements.
I remember you speaking highly of the Shiseido blushes. Many years ago, Shiseido (and also Shu Uemura) were considered THE brands for the best face powder and I really love their Retinol face and eye masks - those things work like magic.