I am motivated by your ordering Earthshine, Pinkdollface....
I ordered 3 of the 4 MSFs...LY, SW and CotU...And I am soooo tempted to get ES. But from what I tried in-store, a light hand results in bronzy gold dust on my NC40 tone and any attempt to make it show up differently makes it look way to muddy on me...! I should perhaps get it just to stop me lemming....but I rarely wear my bronzy MSFs like Comfort....or even Goldstone, even though I like how they swatch on the hand. * SO TORN!! *
I do not have a light hand...and am rubbish with dark blush/ MSFs... need the idiot-proof variety else would look like a clown!
I did not go after the blushes that came with HC, since I prefer matte / satin blushes and like to go over them with the MSF... and while I was sorely tempted by Ring Of Saturn, I already have Stereo Rose MSF and Early Morning MB. Also, I am positive, Early morning + Light Year MSF will yield Ring of Saturn like results. Plus CotU is on its way. The other MBs in this collection did not tempt me. SR was too light and the rest were scary given my "level of expertise" with application.
Thankfully nothing is sold out in the UK (not surprising with the recession!) so I have some time to mull it over. The previous collections did not do too well either. I think after Iris Apfel and then the big Blush Collection - I forget the name, there has been a real lull around here.