I agree that people should need to show that they continue to work in the industry to gain Pro privileges; I was once a volunteer fire fighter but I don't ask for a discount when I go to the local pub that gives cops and firefighters one. I don't do the job and I don't deserve the discount. It shouldn't be a lifetime thing.
I understand the business reasons why MAC releases to Pros early. Unfortunately, the policy is being widely abused, even if only by a minority of Pro members. As such, I think the policy should be reviewed, which is exactlly what I told MAC in the letter I fired off after the Marilyn collection was launched.
If MAC is going to continue to launch early to Pros, I think they should do one of two things:
1) Limit quantities to 2 and disallow subsequent orders (their systems should certainly be able to do that)
2) Limit early launch quantities and leave most of the stock for the regular online release.
I'm going to disagree with you that people don't stop buying MAC. That might be true on this board, but I've read scads of comments in other places (T, for one) where people state that they don't buy collections anymore. I'm at that point myself. Unless I can pre-order something, I'm just not bothering. There are enough other companies that don't indulge in this nonsense out there and I don't consider stalking fun. New people come along and perhaps MAC is counting on getting as many new clients as they lose, but that's a shortsighted long-term business strategy.
This isn't personal, but if you're not working in the industry then I disagree that you're entitled to a discount. You're a customer, no different than me. If you resume working in the industry, I think they should reinstate your status. Otherwise, what you once studied isn't particular relevant, IMO.
My university tuition and professional licenses were costly as well; almost all post-secondary education is. I have to believe that most who study cosmetology or related fields do it because of interest, not because it might eventually lead to Pro discounts. (Some rabid Specktrettes might be the exception).
All of the above is my personal opinion; I realize that others may not agree but I stand by it.
