I don't find them similar at all - definitely worth having both (I do).
I love ANF - mine has lost it's pattern and is now flat. I wear it a lot paired with Stolen Moment. The two are probably my favourite EDES, although I have quite a few (Sweet Heat, Rich Core, Modern Pewter and Opalesse - I gave Grand Galaxy and Zestful to my daughter).
I'm going to try to resist Superb. I have a ton of highlighters and I think this might be similar to some of my others
(Redhead, Definitely Defined and Dior Amber Diamond come to mind). I'm trying to talk myself out of this but I may end up going down. I used to avoid this metallic a finish but now that I have the 159 I find I can wear them. Still, I apply with such a light hand that minor differences in colour don't show. So I should skip. Yes.
How many large highlighters can any one woman use? None of mine show even the slightest use, other than Shell Pearl (snake is gone).
Awesome, that is exactly what I like to hear - A firm enable
Jest is my absolute go to shade, it's the only shade I use on it's own all over my eyelid and on me it makes me look more awake and bright eyed - as you can imagine I get through them so quickly so am looking forward to see if ANF will be my first EDES
IKWYM About the mettalic finishes, I don't have many MSFs or similar because I feel my round face ends up looking like a shiny, very round, ping pong ball
The 159 is love though, but I admit my 2 trusty 187's that have been going for 4 years now get most of my attention, at home (not on my clients obviously!) I will buff my primer & my concealer, apply my studio fix liquid, apply my poweder, then my blusher and my highlighter all with one 187 brush - completely gross and terrible technique but it works and its fast lol. Then it gets a serious wash lol