MAC mascara: best & worst?

[ClaireAvril]

i am no longer a fan of MAC mascaras... i liked plush lash and dazzle lash though..
i'd rather go to the drug store.

 

[broken_soul]

Mac is not my fave brand for mascaras but if I have to choose
Best = Plushlash
Wost = Zoomlash

Best other brand for me at least... NYX Dolleye or CG Lash Blast.

 

[BunnyBunnyBunny]

Prolong Lash is my favorite. Lengthens & curls and builds really well as well. My least favorite would have to be Zoom. It lengthens well enough, but the gel formula dries so fast and has a dry looking finish in my opinion. I have also noticed that the lengthened lashes BREAK through out the day making a really... strange uneven-length lashes. =/

 

[pianohno]

best: ...
worst: ALL

Seriously guys, these mascaras are a big let down, you can get things for like half the price which work twice as well!

 

[gingin501]

I Love PlushLash!!!!

 

[MiCHiE]

I love Plushlash, but like everything else, what looks good/works for one person may not work for all.

 

[Chula]

For drugstore mascara, I personally love almost every Maybelline out there. But, my personal favorite is the Colossal Volum' Express by Maybelline.

As for higher brands, I haven't really tried some yet, because I always stick to the Colossal, but I heard amazing things from my friends and other make-up fanatics about the Hypnose by Lancôme.
​

Quote:

Originally Posted by trulynicole I was planning to get a mascara and i have heard good & bad about mac mascara. I am looking for something that lengthens my lashes and maybe a little volume. THANKS

 

[MissResha]

^^yea, colossal is my fav "fattening" mascara ever.

 

[Nzsallyb]

plushlash is my absolute favourite. over here MAC mascaras are cheaper than l'oreal, but plushlash is my absolute favourite of all time! even better than diorshow and hypnose in my opinion

 

[zoegeorge84]

Fibre Rich Lash.... so under-rated, but i love it.

 

[BrowneyedBeauty]

I really like Plush Lash.

Loud Lash and Dazzle Lash are horrible--stay away!!!

 

[gildedangel]

Best: Plushlash
Worst: Dazzlelash
Dazzlelash did NOTHING for me, plushlash curls and volumizes my lashes.

 

[kerasaki]

The worst for me was Fiberlash, because it didn't do anything for me. And I can't understand the hype about Plushlash. It was just an average mascara, and it needs lots of buildup to look good, whereas with Diorshow or YSL you only need one coat and you're done. Anyway, I think Zoomlash is way better.