lets just say a perfect day does not look anything like any of the nude lippies from the permanent range at mac, i've tried it side by side with blankety, hue, shy girl, jubilee, half n half, cherish, creme d nude, and so on, it is a lustre so it has more transparency compared to blankety, but the pink tone in it makes it very different....now if it will stick to your lip, i have no clue...you might want to try a cremesheen formula instead or a matte and then just put gloss on top b/c i find those kind of stain lips and adhere better...or just try the prep and prime lip to create a base for your lip products
hope that helps