MAC Penultimate Eye Liner, is it worth buying?
- Thread starter PinkMelodyO
- Start date
leenybeeny
Well-known member
I don't like it at all. I doesn't give me the really dark line that I get with Blacktrack and also, I find it really difficult to apply. The thing that annoys me most about it is that it stops "writing" if it gets too much e/s on it from my lid.. I have to keep wiping it off on a tissue. It can take me like 5 minuts just to apply it properly.
patatafrita
Well-known member
I don't like it: I used it once and had to keep going over it to get a solid black line
(((
MissAlphaKitty
Well-known member
Quote:
IMHO, I don't understand what all the big hype is about.
Felt tip liners have been around forever and there are good ones in every price point...
Like the other ladies have mentioned...
from NYX to L'Oreal to Lancome to Shiseido and comes in many colours
unless the Penultimate has some magic colour formulation that beats out the others in terms of waterproofness or anti-smudgeness or unique darkness etc... I consider them all the same and would rather not pay $20CAD for what I can get at the drugstore for half the price or less
I use L'oreal and it's excellent and I demand that all my make up be longwearing and it passes the test
Originally Posted by PinkMelodyO
I want to try the MAC Penultimate Line, is it worth it? Or should i go for something else?? Thanks in advance! 
|
IMHO, I don't understand what all the big hype is about.
Felt tip liners have been around forever and there are good ones in every price point...
Like the other ladies have mentioned...
from NYX to L'Oreal to Lancome to Shiseido and comes in many colours
unless the Penultimate has some magic colour formulation that beats out the others in terms of waterproofness or anti-smudgeness or unique darkness etc... I consider them all the same and would rather not pay $20CAD for what I can get at the drugstore for half the price or less
I use L'oreal and it's excellent and I demand that all my make up be longwearing and it passes the test
MissAlphaKitty
Well-known member
Quote:
Like you, I wear brown for all my daytime looks as well
as options, I know for sure L'oreal makes 1 brown & Lancome makes browns and may have a couple browns to choose from
| Originally Posted by kyoto
I like it, but would love to have it in brown. I use brown eyeliner for all my daytime looks. Someone posted that Shiseido has one as well and it does come in brown. They said that they liked the Shiseido better. |
Like you, I wear brown for all my daytime looks as well
as options, I know for sure L'oreal makes 1 brown & Lancome makes browns and may have a couple browns to choose from
MrsRjizzle
Well-known member
Used it once and havent touched it again. nothing beats blacktrack in my opinion!!!
dreamer246
Well-known member
If you have fu*king oily lids like mine, don't bother buying. It smudges.
Otherwise, I think it should be good for you.
