I don't own that many, but I really love Mutiny and Naked (the perfect shimmery nude multipurpose product). I even got a backup of Mutiny when it hit CCO.
I love Milk, Sweet Sienna, Your Ladyship, Cocomotion, Vanilla and Steel Blue. I just recently picked up a bunch of old sized pigments at the MAC Warehouse sale.
Has anyone heard if MAC is going to drop the price on the Pigments now that they have decreased their size?
Gold Mode pigment + Museum Bronze are my absolute fave pigments and my fave pigment combo. I was really conflicted at the CCO whether to get Circa Plum or Museum Bronze. I made the right choice though, I love bronzy browns and this is a gorgeous one.
I like Helium to highlight. It's not the most subtle highlight out there but the pinky sheen is irresistibly pretty.