I bought 3 shadows and 2 glosses the other day and I must say I love them all! The shadows are quite subtle in texture, a nice low-mid shimmer, and very easy to work with. The glasses are a great texture (for me! I like em sticky so i know they are still there!), but don't be fooled by the MAs description if they tell you they are like Cremesheen glosses, or that they are les sticky than lipglasses...this is not true! They are THICK. They do have a nice slip to them, but the predominant fell is thick and sticky, so if you do not like that kind of thing, make sure you try them out first! Also, do not believe ANY of the color descriptions! They are SO OFF.
THE GLOSSES:
Show Me- very pretty mid neutral peach with slight cool undertones ( I see no plum in this at all)
Lasting Achievement- A gorgeous deep berry color. Very 90s. Really Similar to Desire and New Berry lipglasses.
THE SHADOWS:
All three shadows I bought were neutrals as I didn't find the brighter colors to be all that nuanced. (Hot Paprika was awesome, but SO not a color that looks good on me)
Sweet Satisfaction- This is the first My Lids But Better shade I have ever liked on me! It is a perfect neutral champagne, just a little bit of shimmery beige with the slightest (and I mean SLIGHT) golden warmth. Amazing as an inner eye color, but truly stellar on it's own for red lippie days. I am sure there are dupes for this, but I don't own any.
Lie Low- Very warm sheeny mid brown. Not quite copper, not quite caramel. For a warm shadow this works surprisingly well on my neutral to cool skin, especially when used between Sweet Satisfaction and Make Your Mark.
Make Your Mark- Dark chocolate....but not that dark. More like Milk chocolate. I had hoped for darker, richer, deeper brown so this was a bit of a disappointment, but it is still a pretty color and I don't have another MAC color similar. Also the texture is really nice (low shimmer) so it will work beautifully as an outer corner or crease color.
Will try to post swatches tomorrow, and I will also be going back to check out the lip pencils and try to find that "bright coral" l/g that I didn't see when I was there before.