MAC - Sugar Sweet Discussion

[Susanne]

World of Warcraft

 

[AudreyNicole]

Ooohhhh Erine.... Where are you my dear? Ok so after seeing Rose Romance, I am gonna have to skip some stuff with Sugar Sweet. Soooo here come a buncha questions

Do Sugarshot and Dear Cupcake e/s compare to anything in the permanent line or past LE? Are they at all special? How is the color payoff and texture? How about Perfect Topping MSF? Smooth or Glittery? Any color payoff or more of a highlighter? It is anything like Lightscapade? Is it a must have? Thanks for all your help

 

[abbyquack]

Quote:

Originally Posted by caramel_geek Ugh...I can't decide. Is Dear Cupcake unique enough to justify a buy? I don't even know what I can pair it with. I'm on a tight budget, and I'm thinking between Aquavert or Dear Cupcake. Which one should I get?

I would get Aquavert. I am obsessed w/ eyeshadows and even I am debating about Dear Cupcake...it looks kinda boring, not so unique. Granted it's supposed to have a bit of gold shimmer but IDK if that makes it that worthwhile. On the other hand, Aquavert is gorgeous and the color payoff = A+!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Miss QQ I look forward to seeing Peppermint Patty and Seasonal Peach (never came here with Cremesheens) n/l although I'm not a big fan of MAC's n/l. I love the Peanuts Gang. The lipglosses look very pretty in their tubes but swatched very sheer. I love this collection so much and would go crazy if it has special packaging. If only.

I personally am excited for Peppermint Patty also! It is not a normal nail color but it's totally cute and looks delicious!

Quote:

Originally Posted by AudreyNicole Ooohhhh Erine.... Where are you my dear? Ok so after seeing Rose Romance, I am gonna have to skip some stuff with Sugar Sweet. Soooo here come a buncha questions Do Sugarshot and Dear Cupcake e/s compare to anything in the permanent line or past LE? Are they at all special? How is the color payoff and texture? How about Perfect Topping MSF? Smooth or Glittery? Any color payoff or more of a highlighter? It is anything like Lightscapade? Is it a must have? Thanks for all your help

From the pic, Dear Cupcake looks like Soft Flower sorta, only a bit more corally. But don't quote me as I obviously don't know what these look like IRL.

 

[panther27]

Quote:

Originally Posted by xxAngelxx Ooh, I just got my Aquavert and I love it!!! Its so pretty. And I wish I had been around for Lure. That was some HOT packaging. <3

ITA,I love Lure,I have so much from that collection.

 

[OfficerJenny]

As part of my mental preparation for this collection...

Starbucks vanilla cupcake!

 

[GlamQueen21]

The only things that I'm getting are the MSFs. I do want the Aquavert e/s since I've heard that it's a must have. I do want some shadesticks and I'm thinking about getting all of them but I can't decide!

I'm for sure I'm getting Lollipop Loving since I want to pair it with my Sock Hop lipglass.

 

[rachybloom]

Quote:

Originally Posted by AudreyNicole Ooohhhh Erine.... Where are you my dear? Ok so after seeing Rose Romance, I am gonna have to skip some stuff with Sugar Sweet. Soooo here come a buncha questions Do Sugarshot and Dear Cupcake e/s compare to anything in the permanent line or past LE? Are they at all special? How is the color payoff and texture? How about Perfect Topping MSF? Smooth or Glittery? Any color payoff or more of a highlighter? It is anything like Lightscapade? Is it a must have? Thanks for all your help

I'm actually very much wondering the same question about Perfect Topping (=Lightscapade??)

I'm in the same boat

I'm limiting myself to two things from Rose Romance and one from Sugarsweet

 

[ABB113]

Quote:

Originally Posted by OfficerJenny As part of my mental preparation for this collection... Starbucks vanilla cupcake!

Oh no you didn't! I'm trying to cut back, but that cupcake....OMG.....yummy......send one my way!

 

[omgitzstephanie]

Quote:

Originally Posted by GlamQueen21 I'm for sure I'm getting Lollipop Loving since I want to pair it with my Sock Hop lipglass.

I don't know why but no matter how hard I try, I can't get Sock Hop to work on me.

 

[Leven]

I'm not feeling the green granny hair,seemingly un lip-lined and no gloss coated lips in the promo pic lol

Can i get an AMEN!!!!!!?

 

[caramel_geek]

Thanks ya all!

Think I'll skip Dear Cupcake (and save some moolah for Rose Romance). But Aquavert is coming home with me!

 

[caramel_geek]

Quote:

Originally Posted by abbyquack I would get Aquavert. I am obsessed w/ eyeshadows and even I am debating about Dear Cupcake...it looks kinda boring, not so unique. Granted it's supposed to have a bit of gold shimmer but IDK if that makes it that worthwhile. On the other hand, Aquavert is gorgeous and the color payoff = A+!

It's good to know there's another e/s addict out there (other than me).

I am absolutely obsessed with e/s and p/g. I have more e/s and p/g from MAC than any other MAC products.

LOL. I'm still on my way to collecting them. Mind you, my obsession with makeup (more like e/s) just started one year ago. So, I've still got a long way to go.

 

[coachkitten]

I have a feeling that we are going to be seeing dear cupcake e/s quite a bit at the CCO. I just doesn't stand out from the pictures/descriptions I have seen.

 

[caramel_geek]

Hi Susanne! It's been a while since I said hi.

 

[caramel_geek]

Quote:

Originally Posted by coachkitten I have a feeling that we are going to be seeing dear cupcake e/s quite a bit at the CCO. I just doesn't stand out from the pictures/descriptions I have seen.

It's a bit too coral-ish to my liking (from the photos).

Shadesticks all the way for me!

 

[jdechant]

Quote:

Originally Posted by abbyquack Umm and where have you been lately, miss?

Hey!! I am OFFICIALLY back..lol..long story short, I got busy with my mini holiday and maybe hit a specktra road bump..lol..but I'm back!

Quote:

Originally Posted by pdtb050606 what is this WoW game?

World of Warcraft...its a online game that NEVER ends..haha..you earn points in rank and can communicate with other people oh and battle???? I think...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sanayhs I enjoy my MSFs, but I bloody well hate MSFN.

What What What???! Hate MSFNatural?? Hates a STRONG word Sanayhs! lol... How come??

 

[Susanne]

Quote:

Originally Posted by caramel_geek Hi Susanne! It's been a while since I said hi.

Quote:

Originally Posted by caramel_geek It's good to know there's another e/s addict out there (other than me). I am absolutely obsessed with e/s and p/g. I have more e/s and p/g from MAC than any other MAC products. LOL. I'm still on my way to collecting them. Mind you, my obsession with makeup (more like e/s) just started one year ago. So, I've still got a long way to go.

One more e/s addict here

And l/g addict...

 

[NappyMACDiva3]

I can't wait!!! Looking forward to the LE shadows and the shadesticks. I love shadesticks. MSF look nice too.

 

[Miss QQ]

I went in search of Starbucks vanilla cupcake after reading about it here but it is not available at my local Starbucks.

 

[Moxy]

Quote:

Originally Posted by OfficerJenny Starbucks vanilla cupcake!

Grrrrrrrrrr!! SHARE PLEASE?!