Uh-oh, dreamer. What to do now?????????
Moxy doesn't like Petticoat or So Ceylon, Campor and I do, Shadowy doesn't like the BBR. I kinda feel sorry for you right now. Can you get to a MAC store and swatch any. Or, look at the swatch threads here and see what you think.
Petticoat is quite pinkish on me, Blonde is very much a highlight for me, Light Flush is the best thing I've ever owned, but it isn't available (might try the clearance bin). People are swearing by redhead, but I didn't care for it. Maybe you should wait for this next round and see if they fit your needs. Keep in mind you could also by a mineralized blush instead. Those are amazing and have much more pigmentation.
Sorry this is becoming confusing...