MAC - Venomous Villains Discussion

[retrofox]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Cruella: 4
Heartless l/s
Wicked Ways l/g
Her Own Devices b/p
Darkly My Dear p/b

Evil Queen: 8
Toxic Tale l/s
Strange Potion /g
Hot House l/g
Her Alter Image e/s
Vainglorious e/s
Vile Violet e/s
Oh So Fair b/p
Bite of an Apple p/b

Maleficent: 9
Dark Deed l/s
Revenge is Sweet l/g (x2)
Wrong Spell l/g
My Dark Magic mes
She Who Dares mes
Briar Rose b/p
Bad Fairy n/p
Mea & Green n/p

Dr. Facilier: 2
French Quarter g/s
Truth and Light mclp

Maleficent's collection is my favorite

 

[Fiberluver]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

My take this year:

Maleficent: 6
Cruella: 1 (already owned)
Dr. Facilier: 1
Evil Queen: 3

11 products in all!

TTB outranked VV:

TTB:

3 Marine life
2 l/s
2 l/g
4 e/s (1 + b/u + Shimmermoss in pan form: 2 s/punchy, 1 shimmermoss, 1 firecracker, oops! I forgot Humid!)
1 l/l
1 blush

ITG:

2 Stereo rose
4 l/s + 1 b/up
(already owned Petticoat, Comfort & By Candlelight msfs)
1 blush

Ding Dong! How did I forget DTW???

The best collection evah!!

Gimme That! best l/g and the shadows!!! most were to die for!

Well it looks like TTB was my largest haul in terms of themed collections this year!! It wins by 3 products!

I did pick up a few things in the permanent line, though, and B2M for a lot of l/s and e/s.

I have a lot of make-up to dig into from now until February 2011!

 

[Debbie_57]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Cruella: 1
Maleficent: 1
Evil Queen: 2

 

[1 UP Mushrooms]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by laylalovesmac Cruella: 2 Evil Queen: 5 Maleficent: 6 Dr. Facilier: 1 I have to say that I loved the eye products from Maleficent, but the cheek products in the Evil Queen were far superior, IMO!

Very well said!

Cruella: 3
Evil Queen: 2
Maleficent: 2
Dr. Facilier: 3

My favourites have to be OSF & Innocence Beware. I haven't used the MES and BOAA so things may change.

 

[StarrySim]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Cruella: 1
Dr. Facilier: 1 +1 (had Melon already)

*hides in shame. not worthy of specktra forums. doesn't even own carbon in pan form.*

 

[laylalovesmac]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by StarrySim Cruella: 1 Dr. Facilier: 1 +1 (had Melon already) *hides in shame. not worthy of specktra forums. doesn't even own carbon in pan form.*

I didn't have Carbon until a few months ago!

I forgot to count things I already own!

Cruella: 3 (+ Carbon)
Evil Queen: 5
Maleficent: 6
Dr. Facilier: 2 (+ Melon)

 

[TeresitaMC]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by StarrySim Cruella: 1 Dr. Facilier: 1 +1 (had Melon already) *hides in shame. not worthy of specktra forums. doesn't even own carbon in pan form.*

Don't say that!

Of course you're worthy!

It's all about the love for makeup and beauty on here, no matter how much of it you have in your possession

I'm sure you're not the only one that doesn't have Carbon, btw. We all collect at different paces and I'm sure we can all blame the limited collections as part of the reason!

 

[traxter]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Ok so I got frustrated because I couldn't find Bad Fairy and didn't want to buy it on ebay for $$$...so I found a Zoya nail polish KYM that is so close in my opinion. It doesn't have the duochrome, but it's a warm coppery red pinky cranberry and has gorgeous sparkles..it's also $7-8 bucks.

from - Zoya Kym

 

[StarrySim]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by TeresitaMC Don't say that! Of course you're worthy! It's all about the love for makeup and beauty on here, no matter how much of it you have in your possession I'm sure you're not the only one that doesn't have Carbon, btw. We all collect at different paces and I'm sure we can all blame the limited collections as part of the reason!

LOL, awww thanks. believe me, I'm not worried about not having enough. I have waaay too much MAC, which is why I don't haul like crazy. One or two things from a collection every now and then, and it's great

 

[GlamQueen21]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by StarrySim Cruella: 1 Dr. Facilier: 1 +1 (had Melon already) *hides in shame. not worthy of specktra forums. doesn't even own carbon in pan form.*

Don't hide in shame!

You have plenty of time to get Carbon e/s in pan form. I have to replace mine soon since mine shattered.

 

[TeresitaMC]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by StarrySim LOL, awww thanks. believe me, I'm not worried about not having enough. I have waaay too much MAC, which is why I don't haul like crazy. One or two things from a collection every now and then, and it's great

 

[emory]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by Teggy I'm wearing Her Own Devices again today. I think it's starting to grow on me. Gives me a similar glow to OSF, but in a completely different mood. I felt like it needed to be complimented with a contour and highlight though, which OSF didn't.

i really like HOD a lot. i don't use a contour or a highlight with it-i like that i just get that nice warm glow from it. but i also usually wear it with heartless, so i need something more neutral since my lip is so dramatic.




cruella: 5 (heartless, IB, DS, WW, HOD)
evil queen: 4 (TT, BoA, OSF, SP)
maleficent: 1 (BR)
dr. facilier: 2 (T&L, RL)

so cruella wins for me. i would say she and the queen are pretty close in terms of which villain's collcetion was my favorite, so i guess my list reflects that rather nicely.

 

[ILoveMakeup84]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

I got from:

Cruella: 4 (Heartless, Innocence beware, Wicked ways and Her own devices)
Evil queen: 6 (Strange potion, Hot house, Toxic tale, Bite of an apple, Vainglorious, Oh so fair)
Maleficent: 5 (She who dares, My dark magic, Revenge is sweet, Bad fairy and Briar Rose)
Dr. Facilier: 2 (Truth and light MCLP, French quarter and I have Resort life that I got from a CCO)

I can really say I love all of the collection but if I had to pick one it would be the Evil queen

 

[bevcita]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Cruella: 4
Evil Queen: 2
Maleficent: 3
Dr Facilier: 2

Oh and just wanted to share pics of me wearing Toxic Tale. I find that I love it best blotted than out of the tube. Still really pretty and unique since I don't own anything like it. Please excuse the hair, brows etc

and for the hugeness too..

Warm

Natural

Wearing Darkly My Dear if you could tell.

 

[dreamer246]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by Teggy I'm wearing Her Own Devices again today. I think it's starting to grow on me. Gives me a similar glow to OSF, but in a completely different mood. I felt like it needed to be complimented with a contour and highlight though, which OSF didn't. Okay ladies, let's have some fun. When it comes to number products purchased, how did your villains score? I'm curious to see if any particular villain dominated.

Ohmygosh, this thread is full of temptation. I keep wavering back and forth on HOD, and now you're making me want it again.

Cruella: 6
Heartless l/s
Innocence Beware l/s
Devilishly Stylish l/g
Wicked Ways l/g
Carbon e/s (regular packaging)
Darkly My Dear blush

Evil Queen: 1
Oh So Fair b/p
(didn't get TT because I'm using Coral Polyp as my dupe. Does that count? )

Maleficent: 8
Violetta l/s (regular packaging)
Dark Deek l/s
She Who Dares MES
Revenge Is Sweet l/g
All 3 n/l
Briar Rose b/p

I didn't get anything from the Dr. What's-His-Name collection. Oh wait. I do have half a jar of Push The Edge pigment from a previous collection.

Cruella is hands down my favorite, because the colors are very me (sophisticated/classic shades)

. I can see myself getting the most use out of those products. I foresee using OSF quite a bit too.

Maleficent's colors are dark and dramatic, my favorite being Dark Deed l/s, but honestly, they are not stuff that I would wear on a regular basis.

Oh and I've decided to get rid of my Revenge Is Sweet l/g (used one time). It's just too sheer on me and doesn't really show up on my pigmented lips. Blah. I've put it up for swap on MUA, but if any of you wants it, just send me a PM.

 

[sapnap]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

at this point, I dont even remember which item is from which collection.. lol..I just know I love all the things I got


Briar ROse
Both MES
Toxic Tale- I am still unsure of this.. Bevcita it looks so gorgeous on u!
Heartless
All three nail polishes- I LOVE
Strange Potion
I have a push the edge on its way.. and am contemplating Resort life and Cajun.


I do like Hot house and Wicked ways, but now sure how often Id wear those colours.

I am not sure of Innocence Beware.. most pictures Ive seen, it kinda settles into the lips...

am still unsure of the cooling powder. I tried it on and it looked nice, even hubby told me to get it, saying that my face looked good, but he cudnt find out if I was wearing anything on or not.. just wondering if it worth the $$$ or if any other highlighter like NARS Albatross wud do the trick?.. Cajun didnt look too shimmery on me.. more subtle glow. I think I need some enabling/de enabling if its really worth the hype or not!

 

[dreamer246]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by sapnap at this point, I dont even remember which item is from which collection.. lol..I just know I love all the things I got Briar ROse Both MES Toxic Tale- I am still unsure of this.. Bevcita it looks so gorgeous on u! Heartless All three nail polishes- I LOVE Strange Potion I have a push the edge on its way.. and am contemplating Resort life and Cajun. I do like Hot house and Wicked ways, but now sure how often Id wear those colours. I am not sure of Innocence Beware.. most pictures Ive seen, it kinda settles into the lips... am still unsure of the cooling powder. I tried it on and it looked nice, even hubby told me to get it, saying that my face looked good, but he cudnt find out if I was wearing anything on or not.. just wondering if it worth the $$$ or if any other highlighter like NARS Albatross wud do the trick?.. Cajun didnt look too shimmery on me.. more subtle glow. I think I need some enabling/de enabling if its really worth the hype or not!

I see that you've managed to find Bad Fairy. Congrats!

And yes for Innocence Beware, it does vanish on me pretty quickly and settles into my lip lines.

I still love the color though, but it is not backup worthy in my opinion. Will have to check out Hue next!

 

[peachsuns]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Cruella: 2
Evil Queen: 2
Maleficent: 3
Dr. Facilier: 1 (+ Push The Edge pg)

I didn't include the backups.

So, has anyone tried Bite of an Apple? Am I the only one who's still scared to try it?

 

[laylalovesmac]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Quote:

Originally Posted by peachsuns Cruella: 2 Evil Queen: 2 Maleficent: 3 Dr. Facilier: 1 (+ Push The Edge pg) I didn't include the backups. So, has anyone tried Bite of an Apple? Am I the only one who's still scared to try it?

Oooh what did you backup???

And I love BOAA! I have worn it everyday for the past week or so.

 

[sapnap]

Re: MAC - Venomous Villains discussion

Yup Winnie, I had written about my airport story where I ended up ffinding it