I used this mascara for the first time today over my usual Shiseido Mascara Base. What a difference from what I was using before! Less volume but a lot more length and GREAT separation! I also loved it for getting my bottom lashes because it's a lot smaller brush than what I'm used to. I got to lashes I didn't even know existed on me!
My only complaint is that coming from using a clubbing ultra waterproof mascara, this is a little hard for my watery eyes to get used to. I've had to blot mascara from under my eyes just a few times. So the only thing I wish is that it came in a waterproof formula, because if it did, it would totally be HG for me!