Milani e/s sustitues for MAC e/s

[thelilprincess]

hi all, it took me a long time to search the forums for milani swatches and what could duplicate for MAC e/s. so i decided to start a thread with all the colors i found listed so far....and if you pick up new Milani colors and figure out what they could sustitute for in the MAC collection please share and I will update this post so we can find all the colors subs in the first post instead of having to filter thru lots of them.

Milani e/s--------------------MAC e/s

Almondine---------------------Brule
Antique Gold------------------Sumptuous Olive
Atlantis-----------------------Electric Eel
Blue Ice-----------------------?
*Blue Jeans-------------------Unreal Blue
Classic Beige------------------Shroom or Nylon
Clover------------------------Humid
Desert Sun--------------------?
*Desire-----------------------Trax
Enchantment------------------Parfait Amour
Evening Sky-------------------Deep Truth or Contrast??
Exotic Berry-------------------?
Fiji Flower---------------------?
Flare--------------------------Coppering
Garden Mist-------------------Juxt
Golden Bronze-----------------Woodwinked
Heavenly Pink------------------?
*Icy Plum---------------------Shale, Idol Eyes
Illusion------------------------Little Madame
Java Bean --------------------Sable or Mulch
Limbo-Lime--------------------Guacamole
*Marooned--------------------Sketch
*Mercury----------------------Silver Pigment
Moonlight----------------------Vellum
Peachy Peach------------------Jest
Pink-A-Dilly---------------------?
Rich Chocolate------------------?
Sea Angel----------------------?
Sheer Sand--------------------Shroom
Shock--------------------------Stars N' Rockets
Silver Bullet---------------------?
Snow Frost---------------------Vanilla
Spice---------------------------Antiqued
Storm---------------------------Black Tied
Sungoddess---------------------Amber Lights
Taffy---------------------------Pink Freeze or Pink Venus

*Don’t know if these are available because they're not listed on Milani Website

 

[thelilprincess]

anyone try any other milani e/s colors that hasn't been listed???

 

[NaturalSister19]

I've been having a ball doing side by side swatches today after my mini-haul of six Milani Shadows for $1.75 each.

I'm headed to another CVS on Sunday, I'll post what I find of different.

 

[red]

Quote:

Originally Posted by NaturalSister19 I've been having a ball doing side by side swatches today after my mini-haul of six Milani Shadows for $1.75 each. I'm headed to another CVS on Sunday, I'll post what I find of different.

Me too!!! they were 50% off at my local CVS

I took some picture, will post in a bit

 

[red]

Here are some pics of my Milani haul

you can get the look of Mac for dirt cheap

Milani SHEER SAND & SPICE




Milani FLARE & DESERT SUN

 

[red]

MILANI "CLASSIC BEIGE" "PEACHY PEACH'

 

[red]

I'm adding some other photos, these belong to a sexy chic named Valentina

- she lives in Italy but loves Milani (I gave her most of these)




The Icy Plum is a dead ringer for Mac Shale

 

[entipy]

I couldn't resist the buy 1 get 1 50% off sale at CVS, so Thursday, I went and bought two new shadows: Flare and Antique Gold.

I can't wait to try them! (I also bought two sheer color lipsticks: Pink Pink and Ambrosia)

 

[red]

The lipliners are great, one of them (I can't remember the name) is similar to Urban Decay "Fur" for like 3 bucks

 

[LaChinita]

We don't have a local CVS...My Walgreens has them but they never have sales for Milani and my local beauty supply store sells them for more $!

 

[Devon]

Quote:

Originally Posted by red I'm adding some other photos, these belong to a sexy chic named Valentina - she lives in Italy but loves Milani (I gave her most of these) The Icy Plum is a dead ringer for Mac Shale

You are a Milani pusher, Red!

 

[Karen_B]

I have both Sheer Sand and Shroom and in my opinion, the two look nothing alike. I've heard that Classic Beige from Milani is very similar to Shroom though.