Up The Amp. That was my only MAC lippie for quite some time as I was more into HE back then (didn't know any better lol) and didn't wear lipstick often to begin with.
Nr 2 and 3 were Violetta and Dark Deed from VV. The rest is history
My first MAC lipstick was one from the Naturally collection : Sweet sunrise. I was really into light nudes back then. I gave it to my sister since.
I only have limited edition lipstick except for Syrup which I adore.
My first lippie was Viva Glam I. I had a school dance and now it is the only thing I wear (on my lips) when I go out at night. I tried going out without it but I just felt like a wall flower.
I want to say this was my first one as well because I heard so much about it. However, I have a feeling it was Fresh Brew. I remember going to MAC and looking for a good nude a long time ago.