I'm a bronzer ho and proud of it!!! I actually prefer bronzer to foundation!
The ones I've repurchased over and over are:
Fake Bake bronzy babe bronzer (gives that reddish, I've been out in the sun glow)
NARS Casino (more on the matte side, with slight shimmer)
MAC So Ceylon and Beyond Bronze (both discontinued so I stash these 2 away and only take out on "special occassions"
)
Also, for deeper skintones, I find that Stila Sun in shade 3 (if you can find it), gives a beautiful glow, kind of like the Fake Bake one but more natural/less shimmery.