So glad I found this thread!!!!! I don't own any MAC pigments because I wasn't sure if I'd like them. So I bought 2 NYXs, can't remember the names but one is kind of gold/bronzy and the other is a shimmery white/pearl color. I absolutely freakin love this things!!!! They both lasted at least 6 hours (on top of a maybelline tatoo base) and that is fine with me. Now, I know what to get for dupes if want them from Mac. Thanks yall!!!!