I got Painterly and Bare Study,
Painterly as a base. I actually bought an artist's synthetic brush for the purpose, from a brand called Lucas, size 10. It's soft and drop-formed, just like 217, but it doesn't absorbe anything, being synthetic. And it's at least half the price!
Being "older" (I reached the unspeakable age of 38
) ,I found that the paintpot smoothes the eyelid out, and also makes the eyeshadow smoother! Bare Study is a great highlighter, I use it on the inner corners of my eyes, and it stays there all day!
Reading about all your buys, and being so satisfied, makes me want to get more! at least fresco rose...