I'm very fair, but I own one of the Wet n' Wild cream shadow palettes, and it has a white, some coppers and bronzes, and some browns. I've yet to have a model I couldn't match with that palette.
I have been looking for an eyeshadow like this forever - I'm NC42.
BB Banana is kind of okay, but too matte. I love Soba but i'm the wrong shade for that, I wish they made a lighter yellower version!
The closest I've found is Cork. It's exactly my lid color, I just wish it had MORE sheen, sort of like what you're asking about. Thanks for this thread, I'll have to try some of the e/s folks have suggested.
Arena has been my new favourite for that and it has a nice sheen that's not too over the top.
I've also used Warming Trend, Patina, Soba, Style Snob, Time & Space.. some of those are LE, but you never know what's kicking around in someone else's collection. HTH