NC15 isn't even really a match for me, I'm more NC5, but the old studio finish matte/satin foundations ran light and work for me. Select Mositurecover NC15 is sorta my skintone, it's a tad bit pink for me.
So let's see, MAC foundations...
- Select Tint- lightest shade is a 20, the NC20 being very apricot-y, and the NW20 being very pink. Works if I put a very light, slightly bluish or lavendar powder over top, but isn't a good match.
- Select Moistureblend- NC15 is considerably darker, though this is a sheer foundation, still leaves a line of demarcation, and is a bit more apricot-y that older NC shades
- Studio Fix- NC15 is close, but oxidises terribly
- Studio Tech- too greasy, runs a tad bit dark
- HyperReal- 100 is too dark, and too tan
- Face and Body- C1 is the lightest of all of them, and is too dark. Almost matches the new Studio Fix Fluid though.
- Studio Stick- too dark, feels pasty and looks bad
- Studio Fix Fluid- Very dark, NC15 looks like NC35 of the old studio finish matte. Did a side by side comparison with my current foundation, and it's a good 3 shades darker.
I've got Gone but not Forgotten hunting down the old matte and satin for me, and I'm hunting for a new foundation elsewhere. I've sent a letter to MAC as well. Here I thought when they go the NC/NW 5 powders that they were going to start making lighter foundations. Man was I wrong.