The Dupe Thread: If you have... you don't really need...

[Karen_B]

If I have Pink Opal pigment, do I need Vapour eyeshadow?

 

[macaddict_xo]

If you have Falling star you dont need Cranberry. IMO I find these two to be identicle on me

 

[macaddict_xo]

Also if you have Zeal then you dont need Slip pink and vice-versa

 

[MiCHiE]

The only true dupes I have/seen are Wishful and Naked Lunch. There is very little difference in the 2. Many of the items you guys are comparing are nothing alike, though. While they may favor each other or resemble slightly I surely wouldn't outright call them "dupes".

 

[GlamYOURUs]

Clarity and Electric Eel AND Juxt and Springtime Skipper are the only ones I know of :\

 

[Lisa J]

IMO, Juxt and Springtime Skipper are quite different. They are on me at least.

 

[DaisyPie]

I find Sushi Flower, Girlie and Angelcake are similar on my skin. They're all different shades of pink, but not different enough to make me want to buy all three.

 

[BlahWah]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karen_B If I have Pink Opal pigment, do I need Vapour eyeshadow?

The textures of the two are quite different - Pink Opal's much frostier and Vapour can come off chalky. Vapour also flashes more blue and Pink Opal more pink - on me, at least. Outside of that, there's no need to rush out and get one if you have the other.

 

[Karen_B]

thanks!

 

[AppleDiva]

If you have Opulent Pearlizer Pigment, you do not need to Soft Flame loose Beauty Powder.

 

[shesparkles]

If you have Expensive Pink, you don't need In Living Pink (which is DC'ed anyway). Now I have three of the same color.

They are very very slightly different, but I can't imagine anyone needing both.

 

[shesparkles]

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaisyPie I find Sushi Flower, Girlie and Angelcake are similar on my skin. They're all different shades of pink, but not different enough to make me want to buy all three.

Sushi Flower is much more coral on me than Girlie.

 

[color_lover456]

Does anyone know good dupes for the Bobbi Brown Velvet Plum Metallics pallette? Especially the two darker shades, they were beautiful...

 

[Danapotter]

Any good dupes for Violet Pigment?

I do not have $20 to buy it right now. Any other product similar to it? Pressed or loose?

 

[marieeve2010]

do you think slip pink is a dupe for neutral pink??

 

[Kitt3n]

Quote:

Originally Posted by marieeve2010 do you think slip pink is a dupe for neutral pink??

I swatched neutral pink and girlie on my NW20 skin and found they are almost identical.

HTH!

 

[soco210]

NEED a good dupe for De Menthe e/s - MAC live chat said Steamy but by looking at the swatch I don't agree and was thinking more surreal... what do you ladies think?

 

[c00ki312]

shroom and jest look really similar on my eyes which i was dissapointed about as i was hoping jest was a bit more peachy.

 

[AppleDiva]

Quote:

Originally Posted by shesparkles Coco or Mauvement, tho Mauvement is chunkier and more prone to fallout. BTW I find Innuendo to be similar but lighter than any of these. HTH!

Mauvement reminds me more of Copperclast than Coco.

 

[AriannaErin]

ANYONE know of a good dupe for the shimmery pinky-beige portion of Engaging MES?

I feel silly that I keep buying new ones when I'm only really using up one side