The Dupe Thread: If you have... you don't really need...

[FiestyFemme]

Quote:

Originally Posted by cocolicouss hey i don't know if this has been asked already but does anyone know a dupe for lollipop lovin l/s and also parrot e/s pleasee let me know thanks <3

I don't know for certain since I passed on Parrot, but I think the shimmery blue in the L'oreal HIP "Showy" duo is supposed to be a dupe for Parrot.

 

[Twinkle_Twinkle]

Quote:

Originally Posted by cocolicouss hey i don't know if this has been asked already but does anyone know a dupe for lollipop lovin l/s and also parrot e/s pleasee let me know thanks <3

Aegean from CARGO is apparently a good dupe for Parrot. And also do a search for "Parrot" because there are a lot of dupe suggestions out there.

 

[d n d]

Quote:

Originally Posted by MacAtFirstSight cash flow PP and rubineque PP cash flow is more gold and rubinesque is more light pink but i feel like they are too similar when you put them on

I think Cash Flow PP is really similar to Indianwood PP. They look so much a like in my opinion.

 

[TISH1124]

^^ Cash Flow & Indianwood are not even close to being similar...One is gold and one is bronze??

 

[d n d]

Are there any non mac dupes for:

Vanilla e/s
Charred e/s

I saw some NYX colors that may be similar but I am not sure.

 

[d n d]

Quote:

Originally Posted by TISH1127 ^^ Cash Flow & Indianwood are not even close to being similar...One is gold and one is bronze??

Sometimes different colors appear different on different skin tones. I feel they are similar enough on my skin tone. Just an idea

 

[TISH1124]

^^^ wow .. I guess so


Indianwood and Cash Flow

 

[juxteyes]

If you have Woodwinked you don't need Time and Space from Neo-Sci Fi.

If you have Nylon you don't need Rose Blanc.

If you have Paradisco you don't really need Expensive Pink.

If you have Grain you really don't need Arena.

If you have Jest you really don't need Naked Lunch (although I love both).

If you have Naked Lunch you don't need Shore Leave.

If you have shroom you don't need Femme Fi- but they both are great!

--------

Blush

If you have Fleurry, you really don't need Dainty, or Fafi Hipness, or Shy Beauty.

 

[cocolicouss]

thanks for the info girls

 

[FiestyFemme]

Quote:

Originally Posted by d n d Sometimes different colors appear different on different skin tones. I feel they are similar enough on my skin tone. Just an idea

I think that must be it. 'Cause I'm in agreement with Tish that they're very different, but my skin is fair so maybe that's why they show up so differently on me?

 

[Shadowy Lady]

^^ they show up completely different on me too, and I'm not that fair skinned. Indianwood does not suit me at all btw, makes me look punched :/

 

[topdogg]

Quote:

Originally Posted by d n d Are there any non mac dupes for: Vanilla e/s Charred e/s I saw some NYX colors that may be similar but I am not sure.

Maybelline Linen e/s is very close to Vanilla e/s IMO.

 

[Shenanigans]

Quote:

Originally Posted by cocolicouss hey i don't know if this has been asked already but does anyone know a dupe for lollipop lovin l/s and also parrot e/s pleasee let me know thanks <3

Check this thread: http://specktra.net/f188/mac-dupe-big-t-parrot-118043/

My suggestion is to layer Electric Eel and Shimmermoss, if you want a MAC dupe. =)

 

[Lyssah]

I have a lot of browns and am wondering what color is dupeable for Mulch? Or is it so original that I need it?

 

[Shadowy Lady]

^^ I think Bronze e/s is pretty similar...from what I remember. I prefer Bronze

 

[MacAtFirstSight]

Fafi Hipness Blush and Joyous Blush
Joyous is more pigmented and stays on longer than Hipness

 

[dominichulinda]

Quote:

Originally Posted by juxteyes If you have Woodwinked you don't need Time and Space from Neo-Sci Fi. If you have Nylon you don't need Rose Blanc. If you have Paradisco you don't really need Expensive Pink. If you have Grain you really don't need Arena. If you have Jest you really don't need Naked Lunch (although I love both). If you have Naked Lunch you don't need Shore Leave. If you have shroom you don't need Femme Fi- but they both are great! -------- Blush If you have Fleurry, you really don't need Dainty, or Fafi Hipness, or Shy Beauty.

thanks for this ...sure glad I didn't get those other blushes *I have fleurry*!! lol but I need shroom and femme fi

lol

 

[romi79_2008]

Do you find Folie and Hush similar? I`m not sure I need both
Beauty Markes, any dupe for it?
What about texture?
Thanks

 

[Karen_B]

Is there a dupe for Nocturnelle? I have been debating for ages if I should get this e/s...

 

[Twinkle_Twinkle]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karen_B Is there a dupe for Nocturnelle? I have been debating for ages if I should get this e/s...

I can't think of one, although I am sure that you could probably find one in other brands, but maybe not necessarily for less $$$. I DO however recommend Nocturnelle. It might be the world's most wearable purple. I've hit the pan on this, and I've only hit the pan on three other eye shadows.