The Dupe Thread: If you have... you don't really need...
- Thread starter sandsonik
- Start date
MacAtFirstSight
Well-known member
Quote:
mulch has gold sparkles and is less red than glamour check. they are completely diff imo.
Originally Posted by ms. kendra
How does Mulch and Glamour Check compare? And what's a dupe for Tempting? Thanks! |
mulch has gold sparkles and is less red than glamour check. they are completely diff imo.
ms. kendra
Well-known member
Quote:
Hi!
Nope, just wondering if it's really similar to something I already have like woodwinked, or retrospeck. I hate getting a color and then realizing it's soooooo close to something I already have.
I didn't know it was permanent either, thanks for responding.
Quote:
Thanks so much!
| Originally Posted by panda0410
Tempting is perm! Are you looking for another brand? |
Hi!
Nope, just wondering if it's really similar to something I already have like woodwinked, or retrospeck. I hate getting a color and then realizing it's soooooo close to something I already have.
I didn't know it was permanent either, thanks for responding.
Quote:
| Originally Posted by MacAtFirstSight
mulch has gold sparkles and is less red than glamour check. they are completely diff imo.
|
Thanks so much!
fallenang3l211
Well-known member
Quote:
Mulch, Glamour Check, Tempting, Romp, Satin Taupe, Gold Stroke (pigment), Buckwheat
| Originally Posted by ms. kendra
How does Mulch and Glamour Check compare? And what's a dupe for Tempting? Thanks! |
Mulch, Glamour Check, Tempting, Romp, Satin Taupe, Gold Stroke (pigment), Buckwheat
ms. kendra
Well-known member
OMG I want them all!!! *faints*
Thanks for posting that, it's a great reference!
Thanks for posting that, it's a great reference!
Elusive21
Well-known member
If I have Rule and Pollinator, do I need Off The Page?
If I have Bright Future (from the Style Warriors), do I need Crest the Wave?
If I have Da Bling, do I need Maira's Magic?
These 3 questions are absolutely killing me right now. The colors in the makeup art collection are so beautiful and I am craving them but I'm afraid that I already have colors just like it and I won't know just how similiar they are until Thursday. If anyone could answer these I would really appreciate it.
If I have Bright Future (from the Style Warriors), do I need Crest the Wave?
If I have Da Bling, do I need Maira's Magic?
These 3 questions are absolutely killing me right now. The colors in the makeup art collection are so beautiful and I am craving them but I'm afraid that I already have colors just like it and I won't know just how similiar they are until Thursday. If anyone could answer these I would really appreciate it.
panda0410
Well-known member
Quote:
Bright Future and Crest The Wave are quite different. Bright Future is a deep dark yellow gold, Crest The Wave is a softer paler sunshiney yellow. They swatch quite differently. Think like a Gold Dusk pigment vs. Golden Lemon pigment comparison.
Indoor No Flash
Creme Royal vs. Crest The Wave
Bright Future vs. Gold (frost) pigment
Outdoor Natural Light
Creme Royal vs. Crest The Wave
Bright Future vs. Gold (frost) pigment
| Originally Posted by Elusive21
If I have Rule and Pollinator, do I need Off The Page? If I have Bright Future (from the Style Warriors), do I need Crest the Wave? If I have Da Bling, do I need Maira's Magic? These 3 questions are absolutely killing me right now. The colors in the makeup art collection are so beautiful and I am craving them but I'm afraid that I already have colors just like it and I won't know just how similiar they are until Thursday. If anyone could answer these I would really appreciate it. |
Bright Future and Crest The Wave are quite different. Bright Future is a deep dark yellow gold, Crest The Wave is a softer paler sunshiney yellow. They swatch quite differently. Think like a Gold Dusk pigment vs. Golden Lemon pigment comparison.
Indoor No Flash
Creme Royal vs. Crest The Wave
Bright Future vs. Gold (frost) pigment
Outdoor Natural Light
Creme Royal vs. Crest The Wave
Bright Future vs. Gold (frost) pigment
chocochip
New member
Hi I am new here.
I am looking for the answer for the following question, and by chance stumpled across this forum.
If I have Nars Ondine and Mac pigment Mauvement, should I get Style Snob?
I just bought Style Snob yesterday, and realized it looked quite similiar to Ondine in pans. I wonder if I should return Style Snob, that's why I didn't do a swatch comparison.
If someone can do a swatch comparison, or share their insights, it would be very much appreciated! Thanks in advance!
I am looking for the answer for the following question, and by chance stumpled across this forum.
If I have Nars Ondine and Mac pigment Mauvement, should I get Style Snob?
I just bought Style Snob yesterday, and realized it looked quite similiar to Ondine in pans. I wonder if I should return Style Snob, that's why I didn't do a swatch comparison.
If someone can do a swatch comparison, or share their insights, it would be very much appreciated! Thanks in advance!
michelle79
Well-known member
Is it me or is Charred & Pandamonium the same exact color?
macluvermre
Well-known member
^^It's not just you, it's me too! They are the same to me too and Knight e/s is not far behind them...
macluvermre
Well-known member
Quote:
Maybe Lust l/g?
| Originally Posted by SpringDancer
Does anyone know of a dupe for Full on Lust lipgloss (LE from The Originals collection)? |
Maybe Lust l/g?
macluvermre
Well-known member
Quote:
Sorry, I guess I should have said that they look the same on ME. It's just my opinion, as all skin colors are different, they obviously won't look the same on everyone.
| Originally Posted by Shadowy Lady
I disagree, Humid is much darker than One Off, it's not just the finish. They don't look the same on me at all, far from it |
Sorry, I guess I should have said that they look the same on ME. It's just my opinion, as all skin colors are different, they obviously won't look the same on everyone.
chickatthegym
Well-known member
I was just going through my collection and found another e/s dupe:
Cranberry and Bravado (from the Take Wing quad) are almost identical. Cranberry is a bit more pigmented, but if you pack on Bravado it's very hard to tell the difference.
Cranberry and Bravado (from the Take Wing quad) are almost identical. Cranberry is a bit more pigmented, but if you pack on Bravado it's very hard to tell the difference.
Anna Phalactyc
Active member
Can anybody say how close Henna and Mink & Sable are to each other?
TISH1124
Well-known member
Quote:
There are comparison swatches in the BBR swatch thread ....Link #60...there are probably more but this is the 1st one I saw
http://www.specktra.net/forum/f217/m...74/index3.html
| Originally Posted by Anna Phalactyc
Can anybody say how close Henna and Mink & Sable are to each other? |
There are comparison swatches in the BBR swatch thread ....Link #60...there are probably more but this is the 1st one I saw
http://www.specktra.net/forum/f217/m...74/index3.html
shesparkles
Active member
Quote:
I think Ondine is much cooler and purpler. This blog has photos of Style Snob, if anyone wants to weigh in: Pink Sith: MAC Style Snob - A Taupe To Warm Your Heart
Also, if anyone missed out on Warming Trend e/s from Cool Heat, or Blonde's Gold pigment, I am ridiculously prone to buying the same color over and over, and I can report that NARS Cyprus e/s is very close to both. It's lighter than WT and the shimmer is more subdued, but barely distinguishable.
| Originally Posted by chocochip
If I have Nars Ondine and Mac pigment Mauvement, should I get Style Snob? I just bought Style Snob yesterday, and realized it looked quite similiar to Ondine in pans. I wonder if I should return Style Snob, that's why I didn't do a swatch comparison. |
I think Ondine is much cooler and purpler. This blog has photos of Style Snob, if anyone wants to weigh in: Pink Sith: MAC Style Snob - A Taupe To Warm Your Heart
Also, if anyone missed out on Warming Trend e/s from Cool Heat, or Blonde's Gold pigment, I am ridiculously prone to buying the same color over and over, and I can report that NARS Cyprus e/s is very close to both. It's lighter than WT and the shimmer is more subdued, but barely distinguishable.
