Great thread! I tried narrowing my list down as much as I could...I guess I love make-up? Shocking!
Surprise Favorites: Banshee, Purple Rage, Hipness, Get Away Bronze, Temperature Rising, Happy Together, Revenge Is Sweet
Most Used: Personal Style, Cha-Cha, Viva Glam Cyndi, Naked Liner, Boy Bait, Prim & Proper, Greasepaint Sticks (ALL!), Instant Chic, Lazy Day, Pet Me, On The Hunt, Innocence, Beware!
Most Beautiful: Azalea Blossom, Ripe Peach, Shell Pearl, Flurry of Fun, Marine Life, Stereo Rose, DTW Lipglasses (ALL!), Oh So Fair
All Around Winners: Greasepaint Sticks, Prim & Proper, DTW Lipglasses, Superslick Liners, Sir Teddy (!!!)
Top 5 Lipsticks: Viva Glam Cyndi, Ever Hip, Lazy Day, Heartless, Innocence, Beware!
Biggest Let Downs: Peachstock l/s, Creepy ass birds on LOL packaging, NC15/NW20 Chromagraphic Pencil, NO Starflash eyeshadows (C'mon man!), Superglasses
Adding a new category to the mix...
Top "WHY did I even buy this?!?" items (different than let downs to me, more like...this is SO not for me, wtf was I thinking?):
Firecracker e/s
Going Bananas e/s
Viva Glam Gaga l/s (well I know why I bought it...but I knew it would be terribad on me and it is, and I'm keeping it, lol)