I always use the same colors! Ugh I hate it. I have SOOOOO many options and always end up back at the same few.
Also, I have yet to create an all black lid smokey eye that I can actually wear. I'm starting to give up on the idea. Maybe its my lid/eye shape that I just can't pull it off.
And last but not least, falsies! I have like 10 pairs that just sit there cause I can NEVER put them on myself. My extremely curly and fairly long lashes always get in the way.