What a fun thread! Loved reading it.
I'm NC37...here are my picks--
Face:
1. Laura Mercier Oil-free tinted moisturizer
2. Concealer- either MAC Studio Finish or Maybelline Age Rewind Double Face Perfector
3. MAC MSF Natural
Cheeks:
4. Stila Convertible Color in Peony
5. Bobbi Brown pot rouge in Flushed Pink
6.MAC X-Rocks
7. Nars Exhibit A
8. Nars Orgasm
Eyes:
9. Cat Cosmetics Hello Gorgeous palette
10. Kevyn Aucoin palette #1
11. Kevyn Aucoin palette #4
12. UDPP
13. Clinique High Impact mascara
Lips:
14. Burt's Bees honey lip balm
15. MAC Ultra-Elegant Slimshine
16. Nars Butterfield 8 lip lacquer
17. Bobbi Brown tinted lip balm in Brown
18. MAC 5N l/s
19. MAC C-Thru l/g (or the Milani Secret dupe)
20. Nars Turkish Delight l/g
Okay, I kind of cheated by picking 3 e/s palettes, didn't I? I can't help it...I'm such a palette/trio/quad kind of girl. I only own 3 single eyeshadows! LOL
The hardest part was narrowing down my blush stash...I'm such a blush nut!
What's funny is that if I answered this question a month from now, I bet my answers will be totally different!