These days Albatross is the winner for me. It's especially wonderful because it is a gold sheen (warm toned) opposed to most highlighters which have a silverish sheen (cool toned). Albatross tends to look more natural on my NC43 skin. Every WOC should at least check this out, it's so amazingly wonderful that I now wear it every day and love the glow it gives.
Also like Vanilla pigment as a highlight, which also has a gold sheen/is warm toned but IMO they are slightly different. Albatross is finer and easier to use if you are in a rush. Conversely, vanilla pigment is very versatile as you can also use it as an eyeshadow, mix in with your foundation and lotion, nail polish, etc.
These are my two favorites. But I also have and like High Beam and Strobe Cream as a highlight, which are cool toned highlighters and don't get used as often as the others.