Who's That Lady? Comments

[MACgirl]

all in all i like this collection, i only got whos that lday? lipgelee and ettiquite glimmer shimmer, im going back for the other two glimmer shimmers and backs for whos that lady?, the lipgelees are awsome not very pigmented but that shimmer is so pretty!!! i love this collection. I use ettiqute for a base for pink blushes and gonig for the other two for that porprose for my other blushes...

 

[PhonyBaloney500]

Quote:

Originally Posted by PrettyKitty I've tested it with some lipsticks... and it seems like pale lipsticks doesn't work with those LipGelee, they doesn't show up! Cool and Aloof over Bombshell was nice, because you can see some silver sparkles over the pink shade.... In pale shades it disappear!

Thanks for the info!

I have brown shades so maybe it will show fairly well....

 

[Christina Victoria]

I only purchased the WTL Lip Gelee and Dress to Kiss. I haven't opened my Dress to Kiss, but I love the Who's that Lady. The Glimmershimmers looked nice, but they were so tiny.

Thanks for these comments.

 

[glittergoddess27]

I think for a more neutral collection I ended up liking it for the most part. I really didn't like the standard lip gelees but ended up getting Who's that Lady. The other two kinda made me go Mehhh,..I did get the two irridescent pressed powders in Dressed to Kiss and Blushing Femme,.. they go on very sheer and pretty for me,. I use the 115 (I think thats it, the numbers are worn) the standard blush brush and get a great application. I find the 187 to be too coarse for my ipp-s. I also go On the town Glimmershimmer. As far as those I love the color of On the Town but the size is ridiculously small. On of those things I will end up using very sparingly afraid to run out. I would have to buy 5 or six to make them last and that is just not gonna happen. The other two just seemed to oddly pigmented against my fair olive skin. If I had to give a vote to either Naturally Eccentric or Who's that Lady for best neutral collection,.. I would have to go with WTL. Nothing in Naturally Eccentric really worked for me.

 

[PrettyKitty]

I really don't think that Who's That Lady is comparable to Naturally Eccentric...

NE was neutrals..

WTL is sparkly makeup.

 

[Juneplum]

hmm well i liked who's that lady and dame in a dress l/g. dame in a dress in particular looked great on my skin tone, as did blushing femme powder.. the glimmershimmers were okay.. like a liquid pearlizer. etiquette and on the town were the nicer of the 3. ritzy looks nice too, just with a bit more gold..

 

[glittergoddess27]

Quote:

Originally Posted by PrettyKitty I really don't think that Who's That Lady is comparable to Naturally Eccentric... NE was neutrals.. WTL is sparkly makeup.

I was just thinking along the line that both collections are not promoting items like a typical color collection. For instance all the lipgelees for this one are not so pigmented,.. though it would have been nice to get a very sparkly red lipgelee,.. they stayed with white, gold, and a sheer nudelike pink. Guess I am comparing on a different level?

 

[user3]

Thank you for post this. I was wondering if Who's that lady would be just silver shimmer! My wallet is happy!

 

[dobe660]

I passed on the whole collection - not very exciting IMO. : )

 

[midnightlouise]

Thanks for the reviews! I've been so sick I haven't even thought about this collection. (so you know I was reeeeeaaaally sick lol!)

 

[user4]

When I went to the MAC store I noticed the same thing about the pumps... I tried to squirt the tiniest bit just to test on my hand and a whole bunch came out and i ended having to whipe it all off my finger with a paper towel. I would hate to have to do that every time with something I paid for (and it's sooo much smaller than I expected). So I def. think I'm going to be passing on this collection as a whole. The lipsglees are too sheer on me, I see no point in buying it when all of them look like clear gloss on me

... I was sad. I got a sample of the yellowish/beigish one and I kind of like it but I don't know if it's really worth buying. and the powder is way too shimmery for me... i'm not much into chunky glitter... i feel so funny looking with glitter all over my face... i feel like others look fine, but I just look silly!

 

[PhonyBaloney500]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Juneplum hmm well i liked who's that lady and dame in a dress l/g. dame in a dress in particular looked great on my skin tone, as did blushing femme powder.. the glimmershimmers were okay.. like a liquid pearlizer. etiquette and on the town were the nicer of the 3. ritzy looks nice too, just with a bit more gold..

Did you get anything?

I tried all the lip gelees today. I think I liked Cool and Aloof and am considering getting it.

The glimmershimmers are INSANELY small!! I really see what you all are tallking about. It's like the size of lipglass lol (OK a bit bigger than that but not much so...)

 

[Juneplum]

i got who;s that lady & dame in a dress l/g, etiquette & on the town glimmershimmers, and blushing femme powder.. i posted my 2 cents in the reviews forum =)

 

[Hikaru-chan]

Personally I loved everything I bought in this collection.
The glimmer Shimmers are really tiny but they work so well on my skin, mixed with foundation they make my skin glow (my skin looks crappy to begin with).
The Lipgelees are soooo pretty Cool & Aloof is my favourite and they all show up slightly different on my lips.

 

[Noire]

Chicky was way more pigmented that WTL. WTL has the lipgelee sheerness with the pretty sparkles, whereas Chicky was more opaque like the lipglass stains, and it had pearl-type shimmer as opposed to the more particular and multi-color in WTL.

I don't think you'll mind having both, they look different on lips to me, and layer over other products differently.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bluegrassbabe I saw a swatch of WTL, and it looked very similar to Chicky. I am still hopeful...maybe. I will swatch them for comparison when my order gets here.

~Noire

 

[sweet8684girl]

I picked up Who's that Lady and Dame in a Dress the other day. Do lip gelees never come full? Mine only go above the word MAC. This wasn't the case with my Dewy Jube...strange.

 

[joytheobscure]

I only got Who's that lady - my first lip gelee- I like it - I thought it would be somewhat close to flash of flesh or a substitute to wear over lipsticks. The bottles of glimmer shimmers were so tiny I couldn't get one.

 

[bluegrassbabe]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Noire Chicky was way more pigmented that WTL. WTL has the lipgelee sheerness with the pretty sparkles, whereas Chicky was more opaque like the lipglass stains, and it had pearl-type shimmer as opposed to the more particular and multi-color in WTL. I don't think you'll mind having both, they look different on lips to me, and layer over other products differently. ~Noire

After comparing them in person, they are nothing alike. THey look similar in the tube, but so different when applied. I am still happy I got WTL, even tho it is much more sheer than chicky. Actually, I liked it so much I went and got Dame in a Dress too. They both look beautiful on.

 

[spacexoddity]

The only thing I really wanted from this collection was the WTL? l/g.
I was hesitant on purchasing it because of the reviews I've read, but I really like it!