your most hated mac e/s?

[michelle79]

Dear Cupcake from Sugarsweet. It's a horrible e/s but luckily I found out it makes a great blush so it wasn't a total waste.

 

[stickles]

Bang on Blue! It's sooo pretty in the pan, but doesn't show up at all, so sheer and chalky

 

[ginger9]

Me no likey Club.

I can't get it to stick on my lid

 

[MissResha]

pretty much all of the colors from the Fafi Eyes 2 quad. was that a joke? like were they serious when they put that quad together?

oh, and Sushi Flower. It's a very pretty color, but the payoff really sucks eggs.

 

[leenybeeny]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sabrunka PASSIONATE!! GROSS, so NOT passionate at all! I hate this colour, it made me look like I was sick! And for some people I've seen wearing it, they also look sick! Blah.. Red shadows need to usually be more burgundy in colour, so not a TRUE red, otherwise they look ... Err...

This colour works for me if I do not wear it on my lid. If I wear a soft green or something complimentary on the lid and this in the crease, it's faboo

 

[MissResha]

^^passionate strangely works for me too. i was nervous that it wouldnt but it shows up very well as long as i use painterly underneath lol

 

[Frosting]

I don't hate it, but Club frustrates me.

 

[LMD84]

it's so sad that newly minted doesn't blend well... i thought it was just me! i love the colour but rarely wear it because it's so hard to work with!!

personally i hate juiced... i don't like really powdery texture to it - i swear i swipe my brush on it once and fall out is going all over the place because it's so crumbley! i don't know if it's just mine though...

i'm also hating my apres ski that i got from chill - talk about no colour payoff whatsoever! i have to use half a pan just to get enough colour on my lids! so sucky!

 

[BeccalovesMAC]

I fuggen hate shroom. It makes me look like I have ashy eye lids. OMG! I love club! It looks great under a black base. Give it a second chance lol

 

[blackdahlia]

I have to agree with those who said pink venus. This color never shows up on me. Even when i had the Charged Water.

 

[HustleRose]

i've noticed a lot of people have mentioned newly minted, i personally love that color. i use it on top of the moss scape paint pot and i love the way it looks.

 

[cloudsweare]

^I love Newly Minted as well.

Haven't find one I don't like yet. But, I do have a hard time picking up any color with Bitter. Have to swipe my brush a ton to get it to come out

Also. It doesn't look to good on me either.

 

[SassyMochaJess]

pink venus, aria

 

[elique_ang]

I can't stand nocturnal! I look at it in my palette and curse it out. I don't know why but we're not good friends.

 

[ladyJ]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frosting I don't hate it, but Club frustrates me.

^^agree...I also dislike star violet because I can't get it to work for the life of me.

 

[Tahti]

I HATE Kid. I bought it because an MA convinced me it was similar to Omega cause I was looking for a replacement and was in a hurry, so I bought it. It comes out orange on my skin and makes me look like a sickened junkie.

Great if I WANT to make myself look ill, tired and hungover *hahaha -_-;;;* but otherwise horrific.

 

[SpringDancer]

Warm Chill and Gulfstream - I think they were from the Naughty Nauticals collection. They are lovely colors, but the color payoff sucks, the texture is chalky, and they basically disapper when I blend them. When I can get them to work they look lovely - but they are such a hassle to work with!

 

[thespry]

I don't generally like any of the lustres because of the small colour payoff and high fallout, BUT Idol Eyes looks awesome if I use it over the light blue shadestick (I think it's called Silver Bleu).

 

[abbyquack]

I can't say I really "hate" any MAC e/s, although I do concur that the ones from Fafi (the yellow and green ones) were fug. What do you even do w/ those? Even with a base they just did not work! I agree that they were pointless. But I happened to love some of the other colors in those palettes, like the orange one (shockwave) and the all that glitters-esque one. Anyways, I think if you use the right tools, most of these e/s can turn out very beautifully.

 

[sweeteternity]

I HATE Filament the most. I actually like a lot of lustres but this one = so much fail. It was one of my first MAC shadows years ago and now I just think "Why did I buy this?!"

I dislike Pink Venus, Newly Minted, and Jewel Blue also, thought Filament gets the #1 most hated slot.

To the OP: it's too bad you don't like Texture, it's one of my recent faves! However,I totally understand how people may dislike it because of the orangey-ness.