Only 5 products.. Hmmm let me see.
Snowglobe Beauty Powder. I'm probably including this because it's fairly new to me, but it's a gorgeous highlight on my NW15 skin, without being too shiny. It doesn't impart colour on me, it just makes my skin glow
Hocus Pocus Eyeshadow. A perfect smoky eye, every single time. It really makes my greenies pop as well.
Overdyed blush. It just works very, very well with my skintone, and I can sheer it out or build it up, depending on what look I'm going for.
Stunner blush. Nice and neutral. I grab it whenever I can't decide which blush to wear. Goes great with Snowglobe BP as a highlight.
Candy Yum Yum. It's just so awesome. I don't wear it often, but when I do, look out world! It dries my lips terribly, but I don't care, because it's just so pretty. (Also very pretty with Eloquent Air over top of it. EA was a very close 2nd to CYY, as it's nice on it's own with a smoky eye, or layered with other lippies)
I would have included Matchmaster foundation if it didn't break me out so badly. The finish was gorgeous on me, and it seemed to control my oil. MAC Guy, I agree with you about Lightscapade. While I wear it ALL THE TIME, and I like it (after hunting down some bluer ones), it doesn't feel that special, because I know that it's not the same as the original. Also, I was trying to choose products that were on their first release this year.