I've got to report that I had a mad attack last week and bought up 3 of the shadesticks (of course they were out of the ONE that I went in meaning to get which was Street Cool)....
AND I LOVE THEM ALL! They are so smooth and buttery, and I find make a great uncomplicated base that really allow the shadows to grab on and stay on. I also find that when i am using a darker paint pot (like Hyperviolet) that they are great to use on the inner 3rd, so I don't have to haul out another lighter pain pot and another brush, etc. And they are all quite glowy so they really open up the eye when used this way.
My fave is Heirloom. I think for my neutral-fair complexion, hazel eyes and dark brown hair it has just the right amount of neutral pink, with a topical cool sheen of silvery shimmer to keep it from looking like I have allergy eyes. it is beautiful on its own, but also great under so many eye shadow colors.
I totally recommend these!!!!!!