MAC By Request discussion

[cocofiere]

Just wondering, can the pro discount be used on this collection? Thanks in advance for your reply .

Yes, it can. The emails from MAC always let you know on the bottom if the pro discount is available for whatever they're emailing you about.

 

[CartoonChic]

Rocker, Party Parrot, Moxie, Old CYY, New CYY, Pink Pigeon

Sigh, I'm still so bummed that I missed out on Party Parrot and Pink Pigeon.

 

[Suleyma1xoxo]

Idk if tagged is the right word cuz imi new to instagram but she put this >>> #maccosmetics #lipstick #candyyumyum #ebay #forsale

 

[liesierre]

Yes I agree...I was expecting a pinker color BUT I WILL be wearing mine lol!!! I love it!!

all the pictures I saw of Moxie before were pink... and then i get it yesterday and i'm like "whoa, thats pretty much red with a dash of pink"... on my skin anyway.

I really thought it would be more like pink pigeon or quick sizzle type of pink... not like bright red leaning towards being a bit pink.

 

[cocofiere]

I got my lipsticks today!!! Moxie is soooo pretty! I'm glad I got 2!

Today is my

. It was delivered at 10:35am and I can't wait to get off work so I can look at my new babies, Moxie and Rocker! If I fall in love, I may regret not getting backups but that leaves me with more dough to pick up my hold from MAC on Friday (HC stuff I didn't get or backup the first go around).

 

[Indieprincess]

Old CYY vs New CYY 

The new one has less of that lavender-ish tone than the old one, I really dig it.

 

[Richelle83]

Moxie is gone again!

 

[Richelle83]

So the new one has a better formula but the old one has the prettier color. Hm, I think I'll pass and be happy with the one I have.

Yep, if I had know before hand I probably would have skipped the new version.

 

[andabri]

I really thought it would be more like pink pigeon or quick sizzle type of pink... not like bright red leaning towards being a bit pink.

Yeah, I know I just literally tried it on, but I'm really NOT feeling the color. I rarely return cosmetics, but I think I may return it. It is completely RED on me, with the smallest smidgen of pink to keep it from being true red.

For anyone wavering, I swatched it with guerlain liu in the page before this, and it is just as red as that lipstick.

Candy Yum Yum is definitely darker than the original (I've tried my friends before) but I actually like the new color. It may not be as neon (which I'm disappointed with) but it IS more wearable, and pretty.

 

[michelle79]

Moxie sold out again!! I had it in my cart & soon as I went to checkout it was gone

 

[Richelle83]

Yeah, I know I just literally tried it on, but I'm really NOT feeling the color. I rarely return cosmetics, but I think I may return it. It is completely RED on me, with the smallest smidgen of pink to keep it from being true red.
For anyone wavering, I swatched it with guerlain liu in the page before this, and it is just as red as that lipstick.

Candy Yum Yum is definitely darker than the original (I've tried my friends before) but I actually like the new color. It may not be as neon (which I'm disappointed with) but it IS more wearable, and pretty.

I'm sure someone will take it off your hands rather than returning it.

 

[cocofiere]

Just got all my lipsticks and rushed to try them on.

I LOVE Candy Yum Yum. I was worried I was going to look crazy with it on, but I love the way it looks.
Moxie is okay, but on me it's nothing special. It looks more red than pink than I was thinking it would. I bought a back up and I'm probably going to sell it.
Rocker is fab as well. Will look great in the winter.

I'll gladly take that extra Moxie off your hands, sight unseen. I have a feeling I'm gonna love it when I get my box open after work. Let me know if that's

. Thanks!

 

[andabri]

I'm sure someone will take it off your hands rather than returning it.

LOL you are right, my friend just offered to buy it off of me. Spoke too soon.

oh and off topic, but everyone in the heavenly creature thread, or at least those still posting, want to see your flattened Earthshine dome. Any chance of pictures?

 

[OhSoJaded]

Yeah, I know I just literally tried it on, but I'm really NOT feeling the color. I rarely return cosmetics, but I think I may return it. It is completely RED on me, with the smallest smidgen of pink to keep it from being true red.
For anyone wavering, I swatched it with guerlain liu in the page before this, and it is just as red as that lipstick.

Candy Yum Yum is definitely darker than the original (I've tried my friends before) but I actually like the new color. It may not be as neon (which I'm disappointed with) but it IS more wearable, and pretty.

I'm sure you can find someone who would like Moxie and missed out on it. Try swapping or selling it here before you return it! That way it can go to a loving home instead of an inevitable death, haha. Looks like you already found someone, yay!

 

[Richelle83]

LOL you are right, my friend just offered to buy it off of me. Spoke too soon.

Lol! They whole reason you don't like Moxie is why I have a BU coming lol. Maybe using Embrace Me will brink out the pink in it?

 

[liesierre]

Yeah, I know I just literally tried it on, but I'm really NOT feeling the color. I rarely return cosmetics, but I think I may return it. It is completely RED on me, with the smallest smidgen of pink to keep it from being true red.
For anyone wavering, I swatched it with guerlain liu in the page before this, and it is just as red as that lipstick.

Candy Yum Yum is definitely darker than the original (I've tried my friends before) but I actually like the new color. It may not be as neon (which I'm disappointed with) but it IS more wearable, and pretty.

for some reason I dont have that much of a problem with wearing bright pinks... but wearing reds make me feel weird... I'm generally more of a MLBB sheer lipstick person with the occasional brighter pink/purple...but I was not prepared for Moxie...

I haven't even tried it on...I just swatched it on the back of my hand and was like "whoa... ooookay."

I'm undecided about what to do with it though...I may hoard it for a while. My friend wants a backup of it possibly so maybe I'll just keep it for a while and sell it to her later. Pretty sure shes tapped out on $$ for now, lol.

 

[michelle79]

I'm thinking they will do it again, and will probably do it with other products like blush or MSFs.

I would love if they did blushes. I'm still brokenhearted about my Stark Naked breaking into pieces.

 

[nuclearteeth]

I like this iteration of Candy Yum Yum much more than the original. As others have said, it's a lot smoother and creamier and doesn't seem to dry out my lips nearly as much. Plus, the slight shift in colour prompted me to order another when I was able to...the Quite Cute version looked like Pepto Bismol puke on me and I couldn't stand it.

 

[Richelle83]

Very good way of describing it!!

 

[andabri]

I'm undecided about what to do with it though...I may hoard it for a while. My friend wants a backup of it possibly so maybe I'll just keep it for a while and sell it to her later. Pretty sure shes tapped out on $$ for now, lol.

I was worried I would regret it too. So I told my friend I'd give it to her for $10 if I can cut off the tip to keep some JUST IN CASE. I hate the remorse after I get rid of a product, even though i *know* there was a reason I wanted to get rid of it.