MAC By Request discussion

[Richelle83]

Not really. This isn't a trick question is it lol.

LMAO! No it isn't a trick!. Posted swatches earlier and somehow the two looked pretty similar if not the same. Naturally that confused me, tried it on hubster and I can't tell a difference either. Like what happened lol?!

 

[andabri]

Can you tell the difference? Old, New

lol they look the same to me. Just the one on the right looks like a heavier swatch.

 

[bulbasaur359]

I do, let me go check!

Definitely different. FoF also has that duochrome look that BR doesn't have.
BR top, FoF bottom

Dammit lol. They do look different. I have BR but FoF now looks like a possible lemming. Urgh, lol. But, if I get it and enjoy it then it's worth it. Thank you for comparing.

 

[Richelle83]

lol they look the same to me. Just the one on the right looks like a heavier swatch.

Ok good, thought I was loosing it! Tried to make it even but the old is hard to work with.

 

[Naynadine]

Can you tell the difference?
Old, New

Colorwwise they look more similar than in the first pic you posted, but it really does look like the new one has a smoother application.

 

[andabri]

Ok good, thought I was loosing it! Tried to make it even but the old is hard to work with. 

Yeah maybe not heavier but more opaque? Like i can see through the left one a bit more. So what is the answer?! Lol.

 

[Richelle83]

Yes much smoother in application, especially on the lips!

Yeah maybe not heavier but more opaque? Like i can see through the left one a bit more. So what is the answer?! Lol.

Old and new CYY!

 

[Shellcat]

Looks like the same shade. The one on the right looks smoother, maybe creamier looking.

Can you tell the difference?
Old, New

 

[maneater]

Same here! I love MOXIE! I should have gotten a backup too.

Me too. I have major regret right now!

 

[SatelliteDrmr]

Can you tell the difference?
Old, New

I'm assuming new is on the right. New looks a bit smoother, and not as matte. It may be just the slightest bit warmer, but it's really not enough to be noticeable.

 

[Fiberluver]

LMAO! No it isn't a trick!. Posted swatches earlier and somehow the two looked pretty similar if not the same. Naturally that confused me, tried it on hubster and I can't tell a difference either. Like what happened lol?!

Um,

Richelle is that ur husband's arm w/lipstick swatches on it? If it is, geez, too funny! ROFL!

 

[Richelle83]

Um,

Richelle is that ur husband's arm w/lipstick swatches on it? If it is, geez, too funny! ROFL!

Yes it is!!! I'm glad he doesn't mind.

 

[califabulous]

It definitely is not Coral Bliss, I know that much! I kinda would be mad if there was a real dupe for Flamingo considering I have BU's lol.

aww! i was going to suggest coral bliss! lol but I don't have flamingo to compare...i missed it! im not the greatest 'dupe finder' so I don't usually comment regarding comparisons. I often see colors that no one else sees! but earlier someone mentioned sunny seoul (?) from the cremesheen pearl collection as a possible dupe for flamingo. Still, i think im going to get coral bliss...

 

[BeLucky]

Yes it is!!! I'm glad he doesn't mind.

That's adorable. I love it.

 

[drammy04]

GOT MY BOX!!! YAAY!!!! UPS came back around to deliver it to me. (after numerous complaints)

Soooo, suprisingly my favorite is Rocker. This color is GAWGEOUS! I see myself rocking it all fall/winter. I'm so about to order a backup.

As for CYY and Moxie I like them too. Probably better with not so dry lips and/or makeup on. I bought two CYY and might sell it for retail price + shipping. I'm not sure yet though.

They're all beautiful though!

 

[Knope2012]

Here are some CYY comparisons:



NARS Schiap, Maybelline Fuchsia Fix, Milani Rose Hip, MAC Dear Diary, MAC CYY, MAC Pink Pigeon






Apologies for the weird lighting, my apartment doesn't have many overhead light fixtures. DD and CYY are definitely close, but not dupes.

EDIT: This is the new CYY, I don't have the old one.

 

[Jenrbelt]

I hope that some of you who got CYY will post some looks with it! I am curious as to how this ls looks on different skin tones. When you search images of people wearing it, it looks so different on people. Some of them I think are lying about the color actually being CYY!

 

[SweetSarah]

Oh. My God. I love love love CYY. I could kick myself for only getting one tube.

Anyone want to sell me theirs? I have a back up of Pink Popcorn if someone wants to swap.

Rocker is really nice, but I'll wear it in the winter. Moxie, I'm still undecided on. Will have to play with it more.

 

[Lipstickdiva420]

Can you tell the difference?
Old, New

This pic I can't tell.

 

[Lipstickdiva420]

Oh. My God. I love love love CYY. I could kick myself for only getting one tube.

Anyone want to sell me theirs? I have a back up of Pink Popcorn if someone wants to swap.

Rocker is really nice, but I'll wear it in the winter. Moxie, I'm still undecided on. Will have to play with it more.

Sounds really tempting lol.