I'm not loving it on me either. I've tried it with several liners (Absolutely It, Morning Coffee and Burgandy) but I'm not warming up to it. I might swap it away; I'm trying to avoid keeping makeup that I know I'll never reach for. I was hoping for another Glamourdaze and this just isn't it.
If anyone can't find HC and wants one that's been swatched 2-3x, please PM me. I'm going to cull a few items I never wear (NARS Dolce Vita, Star Wonder, etc) and stick them on the swap board.
I don't think I'm a sale/swap person. I lack the motivation and patience. When I'm clearing through my stuff, I just want it gone.
Hot Chocolate - Just given to my 18 year-old daughter's friend who's over and 'has never had anything MAC before!" WAY more fun than selling/swaping and I didn't need to mail it anywhere.
Star Wonder & Flight of Fancy - Given to very thrilled 11 year-old daughter with understanding that she can only wear Star Wonder (which only appears as a subtle glow on her) for very special occasions. Given that it's a dry product and that I'll store it for her appropriately, hopefully it will last until she's a bit older. I've kept powder blush for years without a problem.
L'Oreal Infallibles - Gave most to my eldest daughter and just kept the three I like best for myself. I love this formula but almost neverwear them while my daughter wears hers daily. The three I kept are great one and done summer shades that I know I'll reach for when temperatures soar.
I need to have really covered any redness in my cheeks to wear Dolce Vita. I'll give it another couple of tries before getting rid of it. I find Plum Foolery a lot easier to wear and I don't reach for this kind of shade often enough to warrant owning both. (I'd rather save the space for yet another coral shade that I'm sure I'll fall in love with this spring/summer).
I really don't like wasting products after I've bought them. I know I'll never hit pan on most of my blush and e/s, and I'm fine with that if they're colours I enjoy reaching for. I don't want to keep a colour that I won't do more than force myself to wear very occasionally so I can convince myself it wasn't a complete waste.