those swatches are lovely! TY for posting. I have both of those PP + FF and I have yet to experiment. You are making me want to track down the new LW however.
Maybe you got a defective one? I wouldn't say it makes my e/s flake off but it doesn't make an opaque base so it doesn't do anything to make the color brighter like other ones. It just adds those pretty silver shimmers. IDK, its sort of unique. I wonder if we try to layer it over or under another PP? Maybe just swap it back to MAC for FF??? I did really hate it at first b/c I love the pink color in the pot and I get none of that on my lid, its just like transparent with glitters but the glitters are so pretty. I could be biased, I am sort of a glitter bimbo. It is definitely different from the other PP, and that could be good or bad depending. I am trying to experiment with how to use it. Similar to the pressed pigments IMO, as they add very little color but lots of pretty micro glitter. (THEY migrate though, big time)
I have it but haven't played yet. I think they are still on the US site!
Still waiting to play, I was in a rut today, but in the pot it looks like Rubenesque--an oldie but a goodie! I think less golden than Rubenesque and more beigey-white gold if that helps at all...