MAC Sharon and Kelly Osbourne Collection (June 5, 2014)

Naynadine

Veteran Moderator
Staff member
I have two light nude/pink lip liners from MAC, and every time I used them I wanted to just throw them out the window. No pigmentation, so dry, and borderline painful to use! But I also have the l/l in lasting sensation and it couldn't be more different! creamy, glides on and great colour pay off.
Oh wow, yes, that's what mine was like, too. Seems like they're hit and miss then.
I recently got the clear one from Estee Lauder and like it a lot. It's pretty sticky though, which makes my lipstick last longer than anything else I've tried, but feels a little weird at the same time.
 

Starlight77

Well-known member
I have two light nude/pink lip liners from MAC, and every time I used them I wanted to just throw them out the window. No pigmentation, so dry, and borderline painful to use! But I also have the l/l in lasting sensation and it couldn't be more different! creamy, glides on and great colour pay off.

Oh wow, yes, that's what mine was like, too. Seems like they're hit and miss then.
I recently got the clear one from Estee Lauder and like it a lot. It's pretty sticky though, which makes my lipstick last longer than anything else I've tried, but feels a little weird at the same time.
My MAC are the same way @Naynadine they are very dry and tug to put on. I have to warm them up on the back of my hand first but once I do that they have good pigmentation.

Does the sticky feeling of the EL go away after a bit or remains the whole time? i was looking at that their clear one
 

NaniLovesMAC

Well-known member
These are my exact feelings about DG too.
Ok! So I work up this morning and I have decided that I am living in makeup denial land if I think that I can get dodgy girl to work on me also. or that I will ever wear it. I have up the amp and other purply lipsticks. If it wasn't a matte finish I would get it but I just know it won't work. unless i get super wowed by more swatches. But T's and K's are stearing me in the other direction. I will just live vicariously through the pale skinned girls seeing them wear DG and RH. Or if you have Lavender Hair :) Now I am only getting 3 things: KYY, Bijou, and Cheeky Buggar. 
 

Naynadine

Veteran Moderator
Staff member
My MAC are the same way @Naynadine they are very dry and tug to put on. I have to warm them up on the back of my hand first but once I do that they have good pigmentation.

Does the sticky feeling of the EL go away after a bit or remains the whole time? i was looking at that their clear one
The sticky feeling remains unfortunately :/
 

Starlight77

Well-known member
My MAC are the same way @Naynadine they are very dry and tug to put on. I have to warm them up on the back of my hand first but once I do that they have good pigmentation.

Does the sticky feeling of the EL go away after a bit or remains the whole time? i was looking at that their clear one

The sticky feeling remains unfortunately :/
that stinks. I do like Dior l/l and Chanel has really good ones too but funny thing is I use my NYX ones more. Do you have a place that sells them near you? i'd give them a try.
 

jchait

Well-known member
after careful consideration im retiring from this run. IM PASSING FROM OZZIES. i feel i have enough similar things in my stash and my wallet has enough damage with AA and upcoming nuptials. i will however fawn all over yall girls when you get your things.
tong.gif
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
 

User38

Well-known member
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

I too am with mosha on this.. and will only come in to bug you guys or whatnotthatIdowowell.. lol.

frankly I think these shades are not for me.. I just looked at a Revlon nude matte.. and for the life of me, it looks quite similar. I mean, HOW MANY does it take to find a "perfect" anyting? just more clutter for me with these lippies.
 

MakeupAddict22

Well-known member
I'm thinking about bountiful brown I know it's a permanent item but still want it lol ..is it really that pretty of a liner? Karens swatch made it look beautiful.
 

jchait

Well-known member
I too am with mosha on this.. and will only come in to bug you guys or whatnotthatIdowowell.. lol.

frankly I think these shades are not for me.. I just looked at a Revlon nude matte.. and for the life of me, it looks quite similar. I mean, HOW MANY does it take to find a "perfect" anyting? just more clutter for me with these lippies.
Promise me that you will! lol
 

Dolly Snow

Moderator
I too am with mosha on this.. and will only come in to bug you guys or whatnotthatIdowowell.. lol. frankly I think these shades are not for me.. I just looked at a Revlon nude matte.. and for the life of me, it looks quite similar.  I mean, HOW MANY does it take to find a "perfect" anyting? just more clutter for me with these lippies.
Yay as long as you are here to help me lol
 
Top