Thanks for the nudge to a sober second thought! Definitely gives me things to mull over.. I really do appreciate the advice so hopefully the following doesn't sound too much like I'm making excuses for myself (even though I kind of am). I'm just particular about certain things and it all kind of ties into building and maintaining a stash of products that I love and will use often.
Sin/Rebel: these will fill gaps in my color range and I've already tried them on and made plans to purchase them, but I also want them for the packaging and it's worth the extra $ to me. I know this doesn't make financial sense, but neither does me buying ANY more lipsticks at all for the next few years lol. RHPS is a nostalgia thing, and the different packaging helps me find certain colors more easily and adds to the aesthetic. When I use up my special ones, I'll just switch to put perm lippies in and B2M the black packaging. Bonus if they're in the regular collection because then I can just replace it with the same color. However, I won't buy something just for the packaging if I don't already love the product.
As for NYX.. I tend to avoid drugstore products, not because there are necessarily any large quality differences, but because the displays here are always such a mess. Nothing is sealed and you can't tell what has been used or not. Also I like brand uniformity and try to stick to certain brands for certain things because I already know I love them and it artificially gives me limits.. For example, I only have 3 lipliners, all MAC. If I want more lipliners, I know where to look and I only have a certain selection I can buy. I do this with shoes, boots, purses, clothing too.. I'm super brand loyal once I find something I love.
Irrational I know.. but what can you do!
It makes no sense I know.. but I still want them in special packaging! Lol. If I had to sacrifice something else on my list to purchase those in the special packaging, I would. That being said I have no problem resisting the packaging if it's something I wouldn't buy in the first place.. even though I REALLY wanted that AA compact..
I don't have Mehr (but it's also on my try on list) or Brave! I'm so behind in the great perm lippies.. I just got Creme Cup a few months ago. I'll have another B2M soon that I can use for one of those though.