better black: black tied or carbon?

[BinkysBaby]

I have both and I LOVE Black Tied. If you want to go for a liner, Carbon would be better.

 

[Dollheart]

i have both and use carbon more so, its great to blend with everything and anything
xo

 

[caramel_geek]

carbon

hands down...the best black ever

 

[MizzHotTahiti]

carbon could go day or night.
black tied is most def a nightclub shade.

 

[pinklips1207]

black tied!

 

[SassyMochaJess]

Both!! they both do different things. i like black tied better but cabon is just as useful cuz sometimes you don't want no sparkles....

 

[luvmkup]

Black tied. I used it today as a liner for my upper lids. I also often use it as an outer V color. Perfect color!

 

[lara]

Black Tied (velvet)
Carbon (matte)
Blackground (Paint Pot)
Blacktrack (Fluidline)

Black Tied (velvet)

Carbon (matte)

Blacktrack (Fluidline)

Blackground (Paint Pot)

Hopefully this aids in the ongoing debate about which black looks like what.

 

[SarahAfshar]

Black tied is very universal because it has some shimmer and reflects to it, making it not very dull, whereas; Carbon is a matte black that is dull, but collaborates well with an array of shimmers and satin finishes. I think they are both equally as good, it just depends on what you want to do with them.

 

[GlamYOURUs]

Black Tied gets more use from me and its a bit darker and deeper than Carbon.

 

[LMD84]

i love balck tied and find it easier to blend than carbon. plus i love sparkles which is also why i reach for this one more.

 

[MacNlaw]

I prefer Black Tied, I like the texture & finish better then Carbons...

 

[kittykit]

I prefer Carbon. It's my most used e/s

 

[3773519]

I honestly dont like black tied one bit...I love carbon and black track and now my fav love is pointblack liquidlast liners. its awesome....Black tied because of the glitter it has doesnt mix well when blending with other colors...sometimes it makes one color look green or goldish. And since im a MATTE kind of girl i would have to say CARBON.

 

[April47]

I don't own Carbon but I do own Black Tied. I just wanted to point out that when I wet BT it does not ruin the e/s by making it hard. Carbon however looks like it's a matte e/s and I've had other matte's harden by wetting them.

Also, I don't even notice the sparkles is BT which makes it perfect for eyeliner...

 

[christinakate]

Both, without a doubt.

 

[cupcake_x]

Definitely Carbon.

 

[Zoffe]

If you want a true black e/s then it's Carbon.
It's more versatile than Black Tied since it's just completely matte and black.
They're both worth having but I use Carbon a lot more than I use Black Tied!

 

[GlamQueen21]

I like Carbon! I used it today in my outer crease with Shadowy Lady and it turned out gorgeous!

 

[QTAllStarGurl]

Carbon...just b/c I feel weird wearing glittery stuff in certain settings...so carbon always works