OMG! I always thought I was the only one with this problem! It's so reassuring to know that you lovely ladies also have the same issues. =) I'm a righty and always start with my left eye first which ends up perfect but my right eye looks like a sloppy mess! I have the same problem when doing another persons makeup as well LOL! I'm gonna try Erine1881's tip of starting with my right eye first. I'm keeping my fingers crossed...