Quote:
Originally Posted by aziajs
^^^^^MAC makes me laugh because they are commercial but want people to think otherwise. It's not like they pic obscure people to put in their ads and promos. Everyone has been big stars - Mary J. Blige, Elton John, Lil' Kim, Eve, Dita Von Teese, Pamela Anderson, Christina Aguilera and many more. You gotta come better than that to convince people you are cutting edge and novel. They may have started out that way but those days are long gone.
|
I agree with you to a certain extent. Everyone MAC has chosen so far has seen stardom, however the vast majority of them have something a certain timelessness going on. MAC does need to choose people who are going to be recognized, yet there is a certain provocative particularity to each and every one of them. Some, such as Elton John for example, haven't contributed anything to the entertainment industry in years, yet they are candidates MAC take into consideration. Elton John, aside from campaigning for VG, has his own AIDS foundation. Rupaul, for example, was a huge deal, when the first VG campaign came out. It was provocative to feature a transexual, representing the AIDS foundation nonetheless. It caused a stir. Mary J. Blige, Lil' Kim, and Dita Von Teese, to name a few, are celebrities (A-List ones as well), yet there is something that sets them apart from the rest. They are different.
Fergie, as I said previously, doesn't seem to fit into that mold. She's the product of everything that is mainstream. The days of MAC being underground (and those were the days) might be long gone, but an effort is still being made to revive the roots, and everything MAC was based upon. In my opinion, choosing Fergie (or any other celebrity that has their own clothing line, their own perfume line,
that can sing AND act too) is limiting MAC's progress towards that regression.
*Edit*:
I forgot to mention something. Choosing Fergie means putting her on the same pedestal as her predecessors. In which way does she live up to what Elton John, or Linda Evangelista have done for the company? It's choosing temporary popularity over timelessness.