I do neither. I used to be a slave to working out. If I wasn't burning calories, I was failing as a human being. I grew up as an athlete--elite soccer player until injury took me out of the sport for good, competitive figure skater, sprinter, you name it, I did it (with the exception of softball).
For me, the key to staying active has been finding activities I thoroughly enjoy. I was in a 5-car pile up a little over a month ago, so have been totally sedentary since then with the exception of walking around campus and school and every day movement. However, until my accident, and hope to start back soon, my main two workouts were aerial skis and flying trapeze (circus arts). Those two activities combine cardio once you learn the basics for silks (or when you get to an intermediate-ish level for trapeze) It's so much more rewarding and fun than going to the gym, and I DO actually somewhat enjoy the gym. Once my car accident injuries heal, I hope to get back into figure skating as well. Between the three activities, I work every. single. muscle in my body. I don't know that using exact numbers would be appropriate, but I have the body fat percentage of an elite athlete, can do 11 pull ups (although that may have gone down since the accident), and while I'm slightly underweight, I am extremely healthy.
What are you passionate about (besides makeup
)? Are there any activities you've always wanted to try but never have? There are more than two choices. You could take dance classes, join an adult sports team of some kind (they're generally very welcoming to beginners), go for hikes, swim, the possibilities are endless. Maybe check out the meet up website and see if there are any fitness/adventure oriented meet up groups in your area. I'm part of one called "Adventure People" and, while I haven't gone on any meet ups yet, they do some amazing sounding things like trampoline dodgeball, group hikes, etc.
Or maybe self-defense/martial art classes? Learn how to protect yourself AND get a workout.
If you decide to go the yoga route, vinyasa/flow classes are the best overall workout. A lot of studios offer a first class free or, at least in my area, unlimited classes for 2 weeks for $30, which allows you to get an idea of whether yoga is for you without paying outright for a membership you may not end up wanting. Iyengar (which I may be misspelling) is create for technique, but the flow classes give you strength and cardio. I don't know if there are any of these stores in your area, but Lululemon (a high end workout clothing store) offers complementary yoga classes once a week, and some offer a run club.
Yet another option if you choose the at home route would be to look for groupon type deals for a personal training session. Start the session by explaining to the trainer that you need help building a workout you can do at home. I did this, and it was great.
Being as active as I am, I'll probably come up with more ideas, if you're interested.