MAC By Request discussion

mousygiggles

Well-known member
This is probably a question for Hey Greyness, but how to do they keep perm items looking the same forever but the LE's vary from release to release or are there the differences but since they are not LE we do not pay as much attention?
 

lustandlipstick

Well-known member
I wouldn't worry too much about that one ;) Stealing Temptalia's swatches + no feedback + high starting bid and no description of policies = an unlikely sale. I can't believe so many non-scalpers (I'm guessing, there seem to be a much higher number of listings this time) decided to scalp this time.
I know! It's crazy! I can't believe they would even begin to charge people that amount of money. I'm seriously in shock.
 
I know! It's crazy! I can't believe they would even begin to charge people that amount of money. I'm seriously in shock.
I saw one listing that read "Lot of MAC Moxie and Candy Yum Yum" for around $109 USD! What does "lot" mean anyway? Two (one of each color)? Three? Four? More (ie multiple of each shade)? Crazy indeed!!
 

duckrodeo

Well-known member
Yipes at that eBay listing! There are more auctions or Buy-It-Now sales popping up every day. Knope2012, you are absolutely right! That one seller has no feedback, no actual images and was not very detailed with their listing. I know people are asking all these insane prices, but the amount isn't the only unappealing aspect to a buyer!

To get a better idea for the asking price, look at the completed listings - CYY is showing sales of $50, but anything more than that is with a high number of bids. They might be International buyers who don't mind paying a few dollars more than their retail price for the lipstick. A lot of Buy-It-Now auctions (especially those with the insane amounts) are ending with no sale.

In the 9 years that I've had my eBay account, I've never sold anything besides textbooks on half.com, but one of my family members was a seller who frequently used bidding decoys - someone or a few people in their social circle to kick off the bidding, or to drive the bidding toward the end so that the auction had potential to end at a higher price. It's kind of a way to see "how badly" someone wants to buy the item, too. I'm thinking that more likely than not, the lipsticks selling for more than $80 are because there's a potential for there to be a scalp even in the bidding, whether someone's actually paying that amount or the amount ended in favor of a decoy. I do not know if this is a common procedure, but with this in mind I'm totally thinking that many of these scalpers may just sit on these lipsticks, having the BNIB collect dust, with the prospective to profit never coming to fruition.
 

OhSoJaded

Well-known member
I saw one listing that read "Lot of MAC Moxie and Candy Yum Yum" for around $109 USD! What does "lot" mean anyway? Two (one of each color)? Three? Four? More (ie multiple of each shade)? Crazy indeed!!
Basically means that they're selling one each... Lot = group of items that are similar/identical in nature.
 

tokidokibaybee

Well-known member
Just out of curiosity but does Rocker look like a glittery version of Diva? Just wondering for reference sake. Thx.
they are from the same family, but rocker is very unique because of the glitter and is not as brown/red as Diva. IA with the above, it's more of a deep cranberry red with glitter.
 

Odelia

Well-known member
I really hope MAC puts up a huge restock in a day or two. Maybe then people will regret paying outrageous prices and will think twice before throwing away their money to feed the scalpers. It's just one big vicious circle when someone decides to buy off them.

The people who missed out on their lippies will be happy with the proper restock. Would be a nice incentive for not caving in and buying off ebay for anyone tempted :)
2cents.gif
 

bulbasaur359

Well-known member
I had Diva a few years ago and it has more of a merlot/plum undertone. Rocker is more red (kind of cranberry) and had a hint of glitter.
Thank you. I thought they looked a little different but it's hard w/o a side by side. I'm looking into growing my fall/winter lippie collection. It's blazing hot here but I'm looking forward lol.
 

Copperhead

Well-known member
This is probably a question for Hey Greyness, but how to do they keep perm items looking the same forever but the LE's vary from release to release or are there the differences but since they are not LE we do not pay as much attention?
Me and another Specktrette was not long ago discussing how she and her sister don't think Ricepaper is the same. I wouldn't know because I have the same Ricepaper that I've had for years.
girlhaha.gif
 

bulbasaur359

Well-known member
they are from the same family, but rocker is very unique because of the glitter and is not as brown/red as Diva. IA with the above, it's more of a deep cranberry red with glitter.
Thanks. I appreciate the input. I am really looking forward to receiving my lippies one of which is Rocker.
 

MacAddictNurse

Well-known member
So I wanted to show a friend Rocker on just to show how gorgeous it is I think this is the underdog here anyways I figured I shared with all of you, by the way I have nothing on my face but the lipstick so excuse the closeup of my freckles


def97298e1d411e1bccc22000a1c864a_7.jpg
 

bulbasaur359

Well-known member
Oh, and I think these ebay scalpers are ridiculous. I wonder who would want to buy from them at those high prices unless it's someone international who has no access but still it's sad.
 

tokidokibaybee

Well-known member
Thanks. I appreciate the input. I am really looking forward to receiving my lippies one of which is Rocker.
No problem! I really surprised rocker hasn't sold out, rocker and cyy are my favorites by far from the collection. I hardly every wear reds except for queen's sin and rocker
eyelove.gif
 

mousygiggles

Well-known member
I LOVE IT ON YOU!!! WOW!!! Awesome color.
So I wanted to show a friend Rocker on just to show how gorgeous it is I think this is the underdog here anyways I figured I shared with all of you, by the way I have nothing on my face but the lipstick so excuse the closeup of my freckles


def97298e1d411e1bccc22000a1c864a_7.jpg
 

loulouhex

Well-known member

dear diary, old CYY, New CYY (smoother and not dry like old CYY), Girl About Town, and Show Orchid ..
to me new CYY looks just a tick less neon and less glowy matte...more regular pink-which means it may not look good on me. example: i look great in ruby woo, but horrible in russian red. If anyone who has the old CYY and gets the new one and prefers the new one - feel free to PM me here or under the same username at Makeupalley. I'd love to swap or buy it off you.
bouquet.gif
 

Odelia

Well-known member
So I wanted to show a friend Rocker on just to show how gorgeous it is I think this is the underdog here anyways I figured I shared with all of you, by the way I have nothing on my face but the lipstick so excuse the closeup of my freckles


def97298e1d411e1bccc22000a1c864a_7.jpg
It really looks lovely on you!
 

Latest posts

Top