MAC By Request discussion
- Thread starter LMD84
- Start date
internetchick
Well-known member
I honestly have no strong feelings about what I would want to come back. It would have been nice if they had just asked for general input and then narrowed down their choices from there. There are products I want more than what is being offered.
CoolinOlympia
Active member
I think they should just bring them ALL back!!!! Why not??? MAC can do it! This is just for publicity, so they should just bring them all out!!!!
Mac-Guy
Well-known member
Agreed!
sss215
Well-known member
Quote:Originally Posted by CoolinOlympia
I think they should just bring them ALL back!!!! Why not??? MAC can do it! This is just for publicity, so they should just bring them all out!!!!
The thought has crossed my mind many times. It's the perfect size for a collection, so why not!
I think they should just bring them ALL back!!!! Why not??? MAC can do it! This is just for publicity, so they should just bring them all out!!!!
The thought has crossed my mind many times. It's the perfect size for a collection, so why not!
Mac-Guy
Well-known member
It might get quite expensive (for us) then. 18 products + potentially some BU's.
katred
Specktra Bestie
Lol. That would be funny. I'd definitely be happy if they brought back all the shadows, because there are at least 4 that I want (Mothbrown, Guacamole, Jete, Solar White).
StyleBlack
Well-known member
I'm only looking forward to Rocker, CYY, & CoC to be honest. The shadows all look dupeable or completely uninteresting. Esp Solar White... Carefree pro longwear shadow looks so similar. Even moth brown, I'm sure there's a pigment out there that is similar.
internetchick
Well-known member
Quote: Originally Posted by katred
I kind of wish they'd done stages- first round suggestions and second round shortlisted. Actually, it would have been really cool if they could have let some fans upload videos/ photos to make a case for "their" choice. But that would be complicated and this is the first time that they're trying something like this. If it goes well, I wouldn't be surprised to see them do another collection like this.
That would be cool! Maybe next time they might allow more input. It doesn't really feel like a fan choice collection to me with the way they went about it.
I kind of wish they'd done stages- first round suggestions and second round shortlisted. Actually, it would have been really cool if they could have let some fans upload videos/ photos to make a case for "their" choice. But that would be complicated and this is the first time that they're trying something like this. If it goes well, I wouldn't be surprised to see them do another collection like this.
That would be cool! Maybe next time they might allow more input. It doesn't really feel like a fan choice collection to me with the way they went about it.
singer82
Well-known member
Woh the swatches have totally changed my mind! Guac and Cool Heat are pretty dupable. At first I didnt see the big deal about Jete but after swatches I love it! So I'll be joining team jete now, wheeehooo! And I'm loving Moth Brown now. It almost reminds me of a lighter purpleish version of my beloved Hocus Pocus! I'll be voting for Jete and Moth Brown. Solar White is pretty awesome too, but mufe has a shadow really close.
I think I'm alone on my lippy choices. But I'm not feeling Moxie much. In T's swatches it pretty much looks like what party parrot looks on me. I have PP, QS, and CYY so I'm good on matte pinks right now. Rocker is pretty though, but to be honest I dont wear vampy colors much. I'm actually in love with Eden Rocks. It's more my kind on color. And dare I say I like 3N. It looks like a great nude! I have a feeling 3N, CYY, and Moxie will be the winners.
I agree with Flash to Flesh it is gorg! Cult of Cherry is such a stunning red.
So my new votes are Jete and Moth Brown e/s's, Eden Rocks and 3N l/s (I think 3N is safe so I'll be voting for ER like crazy), and Flash of Flesh and Cult of Cherry glosses
I think I'm alone on my lippy choices. But I'm not feeling Moxie much. In T's swatches it pretty much looks like what party parrot looks on me. I have PP, QS, and CYY so I'm good on matte pinks right now. Rocker is pretty though, but to be honest I dont wear vampy colors much. I'm actually in love with Eden Rocks. It's more my kind on color. And dare I say I like 3N. It looks like a great nude! I have a feeling 3N, CYY, and Moxie will be the winners.
I agree with Flash to Flesh it is gorg! Cult of Cherry is such a stunning red.
So my new votes are Jete and Moth Brown e/s's, Eden Rocks and 3N l/s (I think 3N is safe so I'll be voting for ER like crazy), and Flash of Flesh and Cult of Cherry glosses
princess sarah
Well-known member
Moxie, Cool Heat, Guacamole and heavenly bliss are my current favs to come back
