I work at Von Maur and we pretty much have a no questions asked return policy. It's the worst. And I work in the dress department. I actually had a lady today return a gown that she wore to a ball yesterday and it was so obvious it was worn. It annoys me... bottom line if you don't want to pay the price don't come into a high end store. If my sales goal wasn't soo much and I didn't have to keep up with it to not get fired I would care less and just think how embarrassing it is for the person but I literally want to strangle people haha. I personally never return anything- If I buy something I know I'm keeping it.
I'm the same way! And I've been on your end of it as well. I've worked at cosmetics counters and had some truly irritating return situations. I remember one woman was returning an eye pencil because it "wasn't sharpening right anymore". It was down to little more than a nub. I asked her if she wanted to exchange it for a different eye pencil and she said yes. I asked her if she knew what kind she wanted and she said she wanted THE SAME ONE. So she wasn't happy with the way the pencil was sharpening, but she wanted to get another one? If there was something wrong with it, that would be one thing, but there wasn't a thing wrong! AND she said she wanted the same pencil because she's been wearing it for the past 10 years. In my head I was like "And you probably only paid for it the first time you bought it and you've been exchanging for new ones ever since."
Love a good return policy, but I agree that they can get VERY abused sometimes. No wonder it's so hard for stores to make money anymore.
Personally, I've only ever returned 2 makeup products. One was a set of MAC pigments (the chunky kind) that did not look at all in person how it looked online. After that, I stopped buying makeup online unless I was
sure I would like the color. The other was a Diorshow mascara. It just cost way too much money to justify keeping it when it did zilch for my lashes. I would've returned a YSL mascara too because it made my eyes sting like hell by the end of each day, but I didn't make the connection that it was the mascara causing the problem until after a couple of weeks wearing it, and by then I had tossed the box. In my 12 years or so of being a makeup hoarder, I think that's a pretty good track record.