MAC Penultimate Eye Liner, is it worth buying?

[PinkMelodyO]

I want to try the MAC Penultimate Line, is it worth it? Or should i go for something else??

Thanks in advance!

!

 

[bAbY_cHiCkEn01]

No, this is awesome. I too questioned what it was like compared to the original MAC liquid eyeliner and his is far easier to control and you can go as thick or thin as you like! The original is always much thicker than I'd like.
This is very simple to use!

 

[zabbazooey]

I have a REALLY hard time using it. I don't like it at all

 

[miss-lilly]

Personally, I love it!!

I agree with the previous poster, I too find it very easy to control and draw a perfect line. My only concern is that it may dry out easily...

I definitely think that you should try it out though

 

[Totally random]

Does this one smudge?
I am asian, and my eyelids kind of hangs over my upper eyelines. Hard to explain...So I can't wear eyeliner that smudges easily...

 

[Donut]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Totally random Does this one smudge? I am asian, and my eyelids kind of hangs over my upper eyelines. Hard to explain...So I can't wear eyeliner that smudges easily...

I'm Asian too and I have the same eyelids. It dries very quickly, almost immediately so it doesn't smudge.

I love mine too. But it's not a must have. I find myself reaching for fluidline more often, but that just may be because I'm used to it and find it easier to use, not that Penultimate is not easy to use.

 

[M.A.C. head.]

At first I hated it, and then I liked it, but now I'm back to hating it and bashing myself over the head for buying a back up. I still think I'm using it wrong. It seems like mine always runs out of color as I'm doing my liner, so I have to flick it and such.

 

[Totally random]

Quote:

Originally Posted by M.A.C. head. At first I hated it, and then I liked it, but now I'm back to hating it and bashing myself over the head for buying a back up. I still think I'm using it wrong. It seems like mine always runs out of color as I'm doing my liner, so I have to flick it and such.

Do you want to sell yours (if it's black)?
I am interested.

 

[kyoto]

I like it, but would love to have it in brown. I use brown eyeliner for all my daytime looks. Someone posted that Shiseido has one as well and it does come in brown. They said that they liked the Shiseido better.

 

[Septemba]

I think it's going to be perm? I'm ordering it this week so I hope it's worth it! It looks like it'll be much easier to handle.

 

[PinkMelodyO]

Thanks guys! I'm going to buy it tomorrow

 

[GlamYOURUs]

No. The NYX Felt Tip Pen is nearly the same as this one. But more affordable. I use my NYX the most in Extreme Black.

 

[melissy]

I got mine last week and lovee it. I would def buy it. I find a lot of the time for me my eye lids seem oily no matter what i do and by the middle of the day than my eyeliner is smudged on the top of my eyelid.. not pretty looking LOL.. well i have been using this now every single day and it has not happened to me once.. i love it when this one wears out i am def gonna buy another one

 

[nursee81]

I have heard good thing about this liner and I am very interested in buying it. Should I wait to finish my fluid line?

 

[abbey_08]

i love it but last time i did a wing look it did smudged REALLY badly down the side of my face by the end of the day. so now im really careful! it is the easiest liner to use in the entire world though.

 

[IvyTrini]

This product is absolutely worth it!!! It gives the thinnest line every. Very smooth and gets really close to the lashes. Dries quickly and you could build up the line to make it thicker. I hope they come out in more colours!

 

[vocaltest]

no, it isn't.
i bought it, thought i loved it, now i don't. its good for carrying around in your make up bag (much easier than fluidline) but thats about it. i'm probably gonna sell mine.

 

[TISH1124]

I do not like it at all...Used it once and haven't touched it since

 

[Darkness]

To be honest I'm not keen on it. I find it tricky to get the line straight and I have been using black liquid eyeliner for a very very long time. Also, I noticed you have to keep going over it to get a good solid black line if you are doing a winged/cat eye look. I have only used it a couple of times and seems like it's running out already; like a felt tip pen does. I certainly won't be repurchasing again, it is a pity as I had such high hopes for this too.

 

[M.A.C. head.]

I figured out that it comes out better when you use it on its side and press it a little harder.