MAC - Sugar Sweet Discussion
- Thread starter Susanne
- Start date
Sanayhs
Well-known member
Quote:
You freak.
I had to pile that shit on, or use it to change the colour of a base. Bleh. Aquavert is so much friendlier.
Originally Posted by Moxy
I adore mine 
I do seem to be a phenomenon, Warm Chill wouldnt show up on anyone and I get the same colour as in the pot 
|
You freak.
I had to pile that shit on, or use it to change the colour of a base. Bleh. Aquavert is so much friendlier.
BloodMittens
Well-known member
Quote:
I agree, Warm Chill wouldn't work on me
| Originally Posted by Sanayhs
You freak.
I had to pile that shit on, or use it to change the colour of a base. Bleh. Aquavert is so much friendlier.
|
I agree, Warm Chill wouldn't work on me
coachkitten
Well-known member
Quote:
I think that you would really like sugarshot but if you already have goldbit then I think that you are safe to skip it.
I meant to do this a few days ago but here are some comparison with St Germain lipstick
Left to Right: Out to Shock, Zandra, Melrose Mood, St Germain, Snob, Real Doll (without flash)
Left to Right: Out to Shock, Zandra, Melrose Mood, St Germain, Snob, Real Doll (with flash)
St Germain and Melrose mood are the most similar of the bunch as you can tell. I don't see any need to have both of them unless you like two bubble gum pink ACs.
| Originally Posted by Sanayhs
Hiiii Katie! I have Goldbit. Am I going to want/need Sugarshot? Is it going to be amazing over Lemon Chiffon? *giggle* Oh dear.
Sadly, I still want the shadesticks and MSFs. Now, though, I'm really wanting another Lollipop Loving (especially if it's more pigmented!!!! 
|
I think that you would really like sugarshot but if you already have goldbit then I think that you are safe to skip it.
I meant to do this a few days ago but here are some comparison with St Germain lipstick
Left to Right: Out to Shock, Zandra, Melrose Mood, St Germain, Snob, Real Doll (without flash)
Left to Right: Out to Shock, Zandra, Melrose Mood, St Germain, Snob, Real Doll (with flash)
St Germain and Melrose mood are the most similar of the bunch as you can tell. I don't see any need to have both of them unless you like two bubble gum pink ACs.
ABB113
Well-known member
Thanks for the collection review, Katie! I think I've crossed the MSFs off my list....I don't need a shimmery bronzer and I don't need another highlighter....I think I've added Sugarshot, though....
Revised list:
Aquavert e/s
Sugarshot e/s
Dear Cupcake e/s
Lollipop Loving l/s
Red Velvet s/s
Butternutty s/s
Lemon Chiffon s/s
Cakeshop s/s
I might remove a s/s or 2.....I'll wait until I see them IRL
Revised list:
Aquavert e/s
Sugarshot e/s
Dear Cupcake e/s
Lollipop Loving l/s
Red Velvet s/s
Butternutty s/s
Lemon Chiffon s/s
Cakeshop s/s
I might remove a s/s or 2.....I'll wait until I see them IRL
NeonKitten
Well-known member
Quote:
i picked up warm chill at my cco and i love the way it looks on me. didn't have to pile it on or nuthin. i
warm chill too
Quote:
god one of my fav greens so bright and pretty
| Originally Posted by Moxy
I adore mine
I do seem to be a phenomenon, Warm Chill wouldnt show up on anyone and I get the same colour as in the pot
|
i picked up warm chill at my cco and i love the way it looks on me. didn't have to pile it on or nuthin. i
Quote:
| Originally Posted by Susanne
These e/s I am most excited about in the next months: Aquavert Bitter Vibrant Grape Bright Future 
|
god one of my fav greens so bright and pretty
dreamer246
Well-known member
Will Refined MSF will show up on me (NC35) enough to be used solo?
I really don't know what I want from here... Maybe just Lollipop Loving, Sweet Thing, and the nail lacquers?
I will need to see it irl and try on everything first before making a decision.
I really don't know what I want from here... Maybe just Lollipop Loving, Sweet Thing, and the nail lacquers?
allThingsGirl
Well-known member
Lightscapade vs. Perfect Topping!
I want to see this too..
I want to see this too..
ladyJ
Well-known member
Quote:
Wait...you were going to pass on the MSFs???!
I still want the 2 MSFs and lollipop lovin. Hopefully nothing creeps up on my list. I feel like St. Germain is!
| Originally Posted by TISH1127
Wow St Germ and melrose Mood are almost twins And my list did change...My sister is getting me both the MSF's as a gift...she knows I am a MSF Whore and thinks I will kick myself later if I pass |
Wait...you were going to pass on the MSFs???!
I still want the 2 MSFs and lollipop lovin. Hopefully nothing creeps up on my list. I feel like St. Germain is!
BloodMittens
Well-known member
Quote:
I second that motion!
| Originally Posted by allThingsGirl
Lightscapade vs. Perfect Topping! I want to see this too.. |
I second that motion!
romi79_2008
Well-known member
Aquavert sold and lollipop loving, and a new mascara, really need a new one. Glad this list is short, I wanted to buy a new es from the perm collection(beautiful iris) but I`ll buy it later( this thing with buy it later because is from the perm collection is killing me...there`s no later with all these collection coming one after another, I barely have time to make a payment to my credit card between them). Really need to cut my expenses like everybody,and I want so much from Rose Romance but I`m having a Csection next month paying full for it and that will get me broke
xpucu
Well-known member
Quote:
I dont have any problems with Warm Chill too and i really love it
But i will get Aquavert too i'm sucker for greens/minty/ colors .
| Originally Posted by Moxy
I adore mine
I do seem to be a phenomenon, Warm Chill wouldnt show up on anyone and I get the same colour as in the pot
|
I dont have any problems with Warm Chill too and i really love it
But i will get Aquavert too i'm sucker for greens/minty/ colors .
Hellokittyqt87
Well-known member
Quote:
reading this makes me remember to stop take a look and try everything before i go L/E crazy lol!
| Originally Posted by coachkitten
I saw this collection in person today at Nordstrom when I did my pre-order. Here are my thoughts. As most of you know I LOVE MSFs and I am getting these although I don't think that they are overly unique or special. Refined would be a good light bronzer (although a bit shimmery) for lighter skin tones. Perfect topping MSF is gorgeous with the lavender swirls but it makes a better highlighter than a blush as it doesn't give off much color. The shadesticks seem to go on a lot nicer than before (even though I know that they are not reformulated). Red Velvet looks like a softer version of crimsonaire but was not overly unique. The only shadestick that really stood out to me was lemon chiffon as I think that it would make a really good light gold base for gold dusk and other pigments. Overall I personally think that the shadesticks can be skipped. As for the lipsticks lollipop loving seems way more pigmented this time around (at least the one I saw). I still can't believe that lipstick is really a glaze. Sweet thing is a a nice sheer bright pink and a typical lustre. Bubbles is really frosty and pale. I don't know how someone could pull this off alone but it would look good over another lipstick. I didn't even look at St Germain or the other lipstick. The nail polish is so cute. A true minty green and reminded me of the color of the double mint gum package. Dear cupcake reminds me of sushi flower eye shadow. It is not very pigmented and kind of blah. Aquavert is just as pretty, pigmented, and easy to use as the Lure one. The eye shadow that really stood out to me was sugar shot. It is the closest shadow that I have seen to the coveted goldbit. Although goldbit is a touch more gold. It is a lustre (I think) but a GOOD lustre. It is so pretty! The tri-glosses are sheer, sheer, sheer, sheer, sheer. Even the one with the magenta color doesn't even really show up. They feel more like the couture line of lipglasses as they are not really sticky. I can see why they are part of the prom collection as they seem more geared towards the younger girls who don't want a lot of color in their gloss. So I ended up pre-ordering: Perfect Topping MSF Refined MSF Peppermint Patty NP Sweet Thing Lipstick Bubbles Lipstick Sugar Shot eye shadow Lemon Chiffon shadestick |
reading this makes me remember to stop take a look and try everything before i go L/E crazy lol!
coachkitten
Well-known member
Quote:
Quote:
Perfect Topping has more of a pinky cream color throughout the MSF with the lavender where as lightscapade has more of an opalescent base with the orange, blue, pink, and yellow colors. I don't know if that makes sense. Sadly perfect topping is not a whole lot like lightscapade in my opinion. They should have re-released lightscapade because it would have been a perfect addition to this collection as it kind of fits with the whole sugar theme.
BTW the MA at my Nordstrom said that they were releasing the sugar sweet collection on Wednesday instead of Thursday. I have no clue why but for any of you that are close to a Nordys you can get the collection a day earlier than normal.
| Originally Posted by allThingsGirl
Lightscapade vs. Perfect Topping! I want to see this too.. |
Quote:
| Originally Posted by BloodMittens
I second that motion! |
Perfect Topping has more of a pinky cream color throughout the MSF with the lavender where as lightscapade has more of an opalescent base with the orange, blue, pink, and yellow colors. I don't know if that makes sense. Sadly perfect topping is not a whole lot like lightscapade in my opinion. They should have re-released lightscapade because it would have been a perfect addition to this collection as it kind of fits with the whole sugar theme.
BTW the MA at my Nordstrom said that they were releasing the sugar sweet collection on Wednesday instead of Thursday. I have no clue why but for any of you that are close to a Nordys you can get the collection a day earlier than normal.
