MissTania
Well-known member
It looks like a groove and where it meets the top of the lipstick, there is no smudge, which I would expect if a person had been in contact.So I was all excited to finally get my Charlotte, the Audacious lippie I've been swooning over since they were first released, but patiently waited for a sale. It arrived today (along with the rest of my shameful stash from Sephora)...and it looks a little weird. I'm not sure if this is some sort of manufacturing defect, something caused by the change in the weather, or if it somehow got touched. Is it possible that it was touched if it was ordered online? I really need opinions on this. It's funny because the exact reason I order online instead of buying makeup in Sephora stores is because I'm so paranoid that somebody could've opened the product I'm buying and swatched it (or worse)...and now I'm debating if I should bring this back to the store tomorrow, since I'll be near one anyway, to exchange it for a new one. I'm posting 3 pictures even though they're all basically the same, but it was hard to get a good picture of the spot I'm talking about. I think you'll see it though. Really in need of opinions on this from my expert makeup buyers (basically every specktrette!). Note: You might have to click to make them bigger to see it.
I've noticed with MAC lipsticks, the sides around the lippie can look smudged sometimes in certain formulas- matte especially, but I don't worry about it anymore.
I'd say ordering online would be assurance that no one has touched it.
I hate buying unsealed products off the shelf, which annoys me about Sephora too.
If you are uncomfortable, then request a new one, it is so disappointing when you buy a product and feel worried and paranoid due to some defect.
Once I bought MAC Lady Danger years ago, and the smell was odd, really super strong, and I got them to swap it for me as it was playing on my mind alot.
Thankfully, these episodes have been very rare for me.
Good luck!!