I have it and it's not the best liner brush for sure, as people have mentioned. Am debating whether I keep or return the backup I got but so far am keeping it. With the exception of the TF liner, I mostly prefer gel liners, yeux stylos or eye shadow. YSL used to make an excellent gel liner and they had a navy color but that has been discontinued. For my purposes, I do a very tight line (no wing) on the upper lash, and the Chanel works. The navy color is a classic cool neutral and a nice change from black to mix things up in more staid work environments. For more of an electric blue, I have a MAC fluidline, Royal Wink. For me, in both the liner, the mascara, and the np fortissimo, Chanel really hit it on a navy shade that surprisingly I'm not finding to be that dupe-able. This is due to makeup trends, I guess. But I feel this collection indicates that people are ready for a return to blue on the eyes. That being said, if you find it too blah for your desired look, I can certainly understand that and the consistency isn't ideal though it does wear well.