Ain't this the truth. I have enjoyed the free shipping, but not much else has impressed me. I have not gotten any of the e-mails for the free deluxe samples mentioned upthread and the Rouge discount was the same as everyone else's last November. Plus, there is never enough quatitiy on the VIB Rouge exclusinve items. I have yet to be able to buy one, and I stay on it. And, this is a bit of a whine, but seriously, they really could have given a full-sized Bite lipstick with the welcome package.So far, the only perk of being VIB Rouge is free shipping on everything. The Rouge program has largely been somewhat of a joke. I'm a VIB Rouge, and I don't even get emails about Rouge exclusives since I became Rouge.